Advertising

The Seattle Times Company

NWjobs | NWautos | NWhomes | NWsource | Free Classifieds | seattletimes.com

The Seattle Times

Sports


Our network sites seattletimes.com | Advanced

The Hot Stone League

Larry Stone gives his take on a wide array of baseball issues and weighs in about the Mariners too.

Blog Home | E-mail Larry | RSS feeds Subscribe

November 8, 2009 at 11:33 PM

Comments (24)     E-mail E-mail article      Print Print view      Share Share

Why I'm feeling (slightly) better about Edgar Martinez's Hall of Fame chances

Posted by Larry Stone

edgarhall.jpg

I've written numerous columns over the years on Edgar Martinez and Cooperstown, and I promise I'll write many more, because the magic moment is coming: Edgar has had his requisite five years out of the game and will be on the ballot for the first time in December. Next month, in other words. Results will be announced in January.

It will be an uphill battle for the reasons that we all know: Edgar (shown above going into the Mariners' Hall of Fame in 2007, surrounded by fellow inductees Dave Niehaus, Alvin Davis and Jay Buhner) was primarily a designated hitter, and a prejudice against DHs remains with some Hall voters; Edgar didn't get 3,000 hits, or anywhere close (largely because he didn't get a regular job until his mid-20s, an injustice that still haunts hard-core M's fans); and Edgar played in relative obscurity in Seattle (although I think this has become on easy cliched response; they have television and the internet and all these other new-fangled things these days that bring the entire world together; why is Seattle any more obscure than any other outpost that are not L.A. or New York or Chicago?).

And yet I believe that a strong case can and will be made for Martinez that shows his worthiness. Martinez in many ways is the antithesis of Jim Rice, whose surface stats and reputation as "a feared hitter" eventually brought him to Cooperstown, while those with a sabermetric bent howled about his unworthiness. Edgar Martinez is an example of a hitter whose credentials grow stronger the deeper you delve into his numbers. I have a hunch that the more sophisticated analysts are going to wind up advocating for Martinez with passion.

It's already begun, in fact. Joe Posnanski of Sports Illustrated (and of his own blog, consistently one of the best reads on the web) has written a post in which he makes an informed case for Edgar as a Hall of Famer. JoePo, in addition to being a deft wordsmith, also happens to be well-versed in the new metrics of player evaluation.

Posnanski calls Edgar "the best hitter not in the Hall of Fame," and explains why. He concludes: "The Hall of Fame is loaded, absolutely loaded with players who were not nearly as good at hitting a baseball as Edgar Martinez. Compare him as a hitter with almost anyone you think in recent years -- George Brett, Wade Boggs, Rod Carew, Billy Williams, Roberto Clemente, Al Kaline or Yaz. You'll be surprised."

Posnanski goes on to say that he doesn't think Martinez will make it, and I don't either -- not the first time around. But articles like this by prominent national writers like Posnanski could begin to change the perception of Martinez as just a DH with good numbers. He's a DH with great numbers -- brilliant numbers, ones that I sense will be illuminated more brightly than I had previously imagined by the legion of great baseball thinkers that populate the writing world these days..

Some work for newspapers, and some are the 10-year members of the Baseball Writers Association of America who will make the ultimate call on Martinez. Many are not; they're the so-called citizen-journalists and bloggers who are changing our world (the world of journalism; my world) so dramatically. I'm not ashamed to say that I've learned a whole bunch by opening my mind and realizing that there are newer, and better, ways to evaluate performance than the ones I adhered to, stubbornly, for so long. I'm not the only one. This statistical and analytical revolution, of sorts, should aid candidates like Martinez as it slowly takes hold and filters into the mainstream, as is already happening.

The Mariners are preparing a packet of information on Martinez's credentials to send to national writers and potential Hall of Fame voters. It all helps. I'm more convinced now than I used to be that Edgar Martinez will, indeed, one day be voted into the Hall of Fame. And that day might be sooner than we had dared hope.

(Seattle Times photo by Mark Harrison)

E-mail E-mail article      Print Print view      Share Share

I'm very interested in this "packet". Is there any chance it can be posted somewhere by the M's, Times or made available to...  Posted on November 9, 2009 at 3:48 AM by japanjohnny. Jump to comment
Edgar had a natural talent but also Edgar practiced - he did his homework, he gave 100% all the time. When he couldnt swing the bat because of...  Posted on November 9, 2009 at 1:08 PM by realfan. Jump to comment
Edgar didn't invent the DH position. He filled the position because that's where the Mariners wanted him to play. He has by far the...  Posted on November 9, 2009 at 7:16 AM by Tboneman. Jump to comment

Recent entries

Nov 21, 09 - 1:39 PM
Aroldis Chapman fires agent, hires Hendrick brothers

Nov 20, 09 - 2:26 PM
Mariners lose Chris Jakubauskas to Pirates

Nov 19, 09 - 4:19 PM
Tim Lincecum on Cy Two: "It just means the world" (plus entire Cy Young voting list)

Nov 19, 09 - 2:13 PM
That three-way Mariner trade rumor and other stuff

Nov 19, 09 - 12:27 PM
Lincecum makes first statement on marijuana incident

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Browse the archives

November 2009

October 2009

September 2009

August 2009

July 2009

June 2009