Swindlers swarm to foreclosures

As home values across the country continue to drop, the authorities say a new breed of swindler is preying on the tens of thousands of homeowners desperate to avoid foreclosure.

Until recently, defrauders tried to bilk homeowners out of the equity in their homes.

Now, with that equity often dried up, they are presenting themselves as "foreclosure-rescue companies" that charge upfront fees to modify loans but often do nothing to stave off foreclosure.

The Federal Trade Commission brought lawsuits last year against five companies representing 20,000 customers, and state and local prosecutors have brought dozens more.

In Florida, Attorney General Bill McCollum recently sued a company that he said had more than 600 victims.

"There's no way for the consumer to sort out the legitimate companies," said McCollum, who added that he had limited resources to fight what he called "a sheer volume question."

The companies under suspicion typically charge an upfront fee of up to $3,000 to help borrowers get lower rates on their mortgages from their lenders.

But borrowers often cannot afford the fees, the service can be bogus and, in the worst cases, the homeowners lose their chance to renegotiate with their bank or to file for bankruptcy protection because of the time wasted.

There are companies that provide legitimate foreclosure services, but the industry is largely unregulated, making it difficult for homeowners to separate the good from the bad.

Some of the fraudulent companies — often run by former real-estate agents or mortgage brokers — are local; others are national.

Many have official-looking Web sites that suggest that the companies have government affiliations and give homeowners a false sense of security.

"That's all I've been doing for the last year," said Angela Rosenau, a deputy attorney general in California, citing more than 300 complaints about fraudulent companies last year, not counting those made to local prosecutors.

Experiences like those of Maria Martinez, of Stockton, Calif., are playing out with greater frequency across the country, the authorities say.

Martinez struggled to pay her mortgage last summer. She had no shortage of people offering to help. Fliers for rescue companies filled her mailbox.

At a seminar for troubled borrowers near her home, one company offered a service that promised just what Martinez needed: For $1,000, the company said it would negotiate with her mortgage company to lower her interest rate.

"I was desperate," said Martinez. She made an initial payment of $500 and paid another $500 a few weeks later.

Now the house is in foreclosure, and Martinez is waiting for the sheriff to evict her. She cannot reach the man she paid to modify her loan.

Carol McClelland, 46, fell into foreclosure on her Chicago home when she lost her job as a waitress in two restaurants.

She received a call from a company called Foreclosure Solutions Experts, promising to stop the foreclosure and lower her mortgage payments to around $550 a month, from $1,056, McClelland said.

"She showed me other clients' files, and they were paying $650 a month," she said. The charge for the service was $1,300, which McClelland paid in installments, borrowing the money from friends and relatives.

When the loan servicer notified her that the house was still in foreclosure, McClelland said, the representative from Foreclosure Solutions Experts told her that the matter had been taken care of.

"She told me everything was all settled; I don't have to worry about anything," McClelland said. "All I had to worry about was getting the rest of the money to her."

According to a suit brought by the Illinois attorney general in November, Foreclosure Solutions Experts does little or nothing to help consumers, and when it does take action, the result is often a repayment plan unsuited to the borrower's ability to pay. The suit alleges that the company never contacted McClelland's lender, HSBC.

Stacy Strong, who runs Foreclosure Solutions Experts, did not return calls for comment.

Advocates say foreclosure-rescue scams are particularly insidious because they prey on people's desperation and because they victimize those who can least afford it.

Borrowers seeking loan modification are often frustrated that they cannot reach the right people at their lender or that the lender insists on a repayment plan they cannot keep, said Ira Rheingold, executive director of the National Association of Consumer Advocates.

"When you're desperate, that's when the crooks come out," Rheingold said.

"You've tried everything, and a guy calls you up on the phone or there's an ad on TV, and you have no other options, what do you do? You go to those guys," he said, adding:

"People probably know in their heart of hearts that they may be getting ripped off, just like most people understood on their mortgages that they were getting in too deep, but bankers said yes, so it must be OK. It's the same thing. The real problem is that we continue to fail to have systems in place that help people," Rheingold said.

Rosenau, the California prosecutor, said that even when she told people that they had been swindled, "they don't believe it, because they want it not to be true.

"And any money they had to possibly work with the lender is now gone to the scam," she said.