Originally published April 28, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified April 28, 2007 at 2:00 AM
Nation's Housing
Cozy setups swelling price tag of title insurance
Title insurance typically is a mandatory and large cost for most home purchasers and mortgage refinancers...ften in the $1,000 to...
Syndicated Columnist
WASHINGTON — Title insurance typically is a mandatory and large cost for most home purchasers and mortgage refinancers — often in the $1,000 to $2,000 range.
Is it priced too high for what you get?
Equally important: Do referral relationships among real-estate agents, title agents and mortgage companies restrict price competition, create anti-consumer conflicts of interest and discourage buyers from shopping for lower-cost title insurance and closing service options?
The Government Accountability Office (GAO), Congress' nonpartisan watchdog agency, made an in-depth examination of the title industry during the past year and came up with some unsettling findings:
• "Multiple characteristics of current title insurance markets, as well as allegedly illegal activities by a number of those involved in the marketing of title insurance, suggest that normal competitive forces may not be working properly, raising questions about the prices consumers are paying."
• Unlike most other forms of insurance, where claims paid by the insurer often amount to 70 percent or more of the premium dollars collected, title-insurance claims amount to just 5 percent of premiums.
Even the five national title-insurance companies, who dominate the field with 92 percent of the business, pocket only 10 to 20 percent of the premium dollars paid by homebuyers and refinancers at closing.
Where does the rest go? Local title agents pocket up to 90 percent of your premiums, according to the GAO.
• Though premiums in many states reflect the work title agents perform to check public records and remove any "clouds" on the title chain, agents also tack on separate charges for title search, analysis of the abstract and "administrative" fees that boost total charges.
In some areas, according to the GAO report, the extras can be "as large as the premium itself."
• "Affiliated business" arrangements, formerly known as "controlled business" deals, are proliferating rapidly and may inhibit consumer choice by locking out lower-cost competitors and by providing real-estate agents incentives to steer customers to title companies in which they have major financial stakes.
• State and federal regulators are finding that many affiliated business arrangements set up to share title-insurance revenues are, in fact, shams. They exist to funnel consumer dollars back to real-estate agents and mortgage companies, rather than to perform actual title-insurance work.
![]()
During the past three years alone, said the GAO, "over $100 million in fines, penalties or settlement agreements" have resulted from state and federal investigations of title insurance shams and illegal referral fees.
These arrangements, which essentially treat consumers' premium charges as slush funds to be redistributed among referral partners, suggest that pricing to consumers may be excessive.
• A key reason for problems in the title industry is that state government agencies that set or approve premium levels often do not examine true costs in depth.
"Few [state] regulators review the costs that title agents incur to determine whether they are in line with the prices charged.
In fact, in the majority of states, agents' costs for search and examination services are not considered part of the premiums and, thus, receive no review by regulators."
The GAO acknowledged that title insurance is an important service and "can provide real benefits to consumers and lenders by protecting them from undiscovered claims against property that they are buying or selling."
But most homebuyers are "vulnerable" when they are required to purchase coverage.
They don't know where to shop for the lowest-priced deal and typically take the advice of their real-estate agent or mortgage loan officer.
The American Land Title Association, which represents insurers and agents nationwide, welcomed the GAO's study of the industry but disagreed with its findings on price competition and affiliated businesses.
In an interview, Ed Miller, chief counsel and vice president for public policy, said, "We would argue that there are a large number of agents competing pretty fiercely for business" — and they offer real choices on pricing and services for consumer who shop.
Regarding affiliated business arrangements, Miller said his association strongly supports efforts by regulators to weed out illegal kickback schemes.
"If they are not set up within the law," he said, "that can negatively affect competition."
The $100 million in fines and settlements over the past three years suggest the system is working and regulators "have gone out and found the [companies[ who are breaking the law."
Bottom line: Don't roll over when it comes to title and settlement services. Be aware you can shop for lower-cost alternatives.
Find them, and you could save hundreds of dollars at closing.
Kenneth R. Harney: kenharney@earthlink.net
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
Neighborhood of the week: The sun also rises on Sunset Hill
Nation's Housing: An era of unchecked fees, thankfully, about to end
Doors still closed for many seeking home-equity lines
Gay renters may get some discrimination protection
Fannie Mae to rent out homes instead of foreclosing

Mourners gather at KeyArena for slain officer's memorial
Mourners gathered at KeyArena for the memorial service of Seattle police Officer Timothy Brenton on November 6, 2009.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- Flags were key link to cop slaying, bombings
- Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
- Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
- Briefs | Soccer: New Mexico suspends hair-pulling player Elizabeth Lambert
- How an underdog named Mike McGinn took City Hall
- Huskies suffer another heartbreaking loss to UCLA
- 3 Cascade Mountain passes close due to snow; more rain, wind expected Sunday
- McGinn pulling away as late ballots come in
- Using anti-shooter tactics, civilian Army police officer brought down gunman
- The birth of 'Grunge,' in photos by Michael Lavine
- U.S. House passes health plan
351 - Weapons, bomb-making materials found in suspect's apartment
336 - Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
243 - Decision day for health care in the House
210 - Grading the game
158 - Referendum 71 show's Washington's strategy for marriage equality is working
155 - Sounders FC-Dynamo playoff Game 2 thread
79 - How an underdog named Mike McGinn took City Hall
78 - Game thread: Detroit Lions at Seattle Seahawks, Nov. 8
74 - Fort Hood shooting suspect had shown troubling signs
63
- Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
- Flags were key link to cop slaying, bombings
- The birth of 'Grunge,' in photos by Michael Lavine
- 10 investing missteps to avoid
- Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
- How an underdog named Mike McGinn took City Hall
- How do innovators think?
- 10 ways to take control of your health
- Tlingit heritage helps glass artist Preston Singletary break new ground
- Danny Westneat | Lee the Horse Logger found slow wagon shrank tumor





