Originally published October 29, 2011 at 7:00 PM | Page modified October 30, 2011 at 9:09 AM
Northwest Living
Puyallup's Meeker Mansion a lesson in history
At Meeker Mansion, where the beauty of late-19th-century housing is showcased, you can almost imagine Ezra Meeker sitting at his walnut desk or his wife, Eliza, practicing at her piano.
BENJAMIN BENSCHNEIDER / THE SEATTLE TIMES
The Meeker Mansion's facades are enriched with columned porches, window bays, balconies, eave brackets and decorative trims.
BENJAMIN BENSCHNEIDER / THE SEATTLE TIMES
The double parlor extends 24 by 14 feet with a bay window as the focal point on one side.
BENJAMIN BENSCHNEIDER / THE SEATTLE TIMES
A carved fireplace with gold tile surround is a focal point of the double parlor. The view is through the entrance hall to the reception parlor.
BENJAMIN BENSCHNEIDER / THE SEATTLE TIMES
The ash wood stair hall extends from the double set of entrance doors to the carriage entrance. It includes a sheltered seat beneath the stair. The balusters form a rhythmic pattern of turned vertical posts and horizontal ties.
BENJAMIN BENSCHNEIDER / THE SEATTLE TIMES
A port-cochère protected arriving family and visitors, who came into the house through this side entrance and into a sunny room with stained-glass windows.
BENJAMIN BENSCHNEIDER / THE SEATTLE TIMES
The front parlor served as a reception room for guests and could be closed off from the rear parlor or library. The ornate wood fireplace surround and floral English tile is unique to this room.
BENJAMIN BENSCHNEIDER / THE SEATTLE TIMES
The second-floor billiard room is undergoing the painstaking process of unearthing the first layer of paint and decoration in preparation for restoration.
BENJAMIN BENSCHNEIDER / THE SEATTLE TIMES
An upstairs parlor finished in ash faces east to capture the morning sun.
Come look
The Meeker Mansion, 312 Spring St., Puyallup, will be decorated for the holidays. Enjoy English Tea on Sunday, Dec. 4. Open Wednesday through Sunday, noon to 4 p.m. Call 253-848-1770 for tea reservations, admission fees and other details.
TOURISTS IN the West love to visit museums in grand old houses. In Denver, it's the Molly Brown House; in Los Angeles, the Gamble House; in Portland, the Pittock Mansion, and in Spokane, the Campbell House.
I'm often asked by locals and visitors alike where the house museums are in Seattle. Sadly, I have to tell them we don't really have any — only some that are home base for organizations: the Washington Trust for Historic Preservation in the Stimson-Green Mansion; the Episcopal Diocese in the Leary Mansion and my own Historic Seattle in the Henry Dearborn House. I direct them instead to the Neely Mansion in Auburn and to the Meeker Mansion in a place even some locals have trouble pronouncing — Puyallup.
When Seattle regraded downtown streets in the early 20th century, high-Victorian-style homes were razed in the process. What didn't disappear then soon gave way to remodeling and newer homes so that Queen Anne Hill, presumably named for the Victorian style, has virtually none left.
What a delight it is, then, to visit the Meeker Mansion, where the beauty of late-19th-century housing is showcased, complete with period furnishings, including some that belonged to its original owners. You can almost imagine Ezra Meeker sitting at his walnut desk or his wife, Eliza, practicing at her square grand piano.
What visitors see today belies all the inappropriate changes and damage it endured under many owners and uses. It has taken years of community-initiated fundraising and preservation efforts to bring this historic house back to its roots.
The Meeker Mansion was quite a step up from the log cabin where Meeker and his wife lived and raised their children. The stately Italianate villa was designed by the Tacoma architectural firm Ferrell and Darmer. Work began in 1886, and by 1890 it was complete enough for the wedding of their youngest daughter, Olive.
The mansion featured hand-painted ceilings, stained-glass windows at the two entrances and fireplaces with English tile.
The hop crisis and financial panic of 1893 affected Meeker's resources. So from 1903 his house was for sale, and the record includes several transfers within the family. From 1906 to '08, Meeker was on an expedition, and the house took in boarders.
After Eliza's death in 1909, Ezra did not return, leaving his daughter and son-in-law in charge. About 1912 it was leased as a hospital. In 1915, the Washington and Alaska Chapter of the Ladies of the Grand Army of the Republic bought it to house widows and orphans.
In 1948 the GAR sold it to the first of a series of doctors who used it as a critical-care nursing home. Dropped ceilings were installed, and exterior woodwork and trim were removed to make way for asbestos siding.
In 1970, an organization was formed to take over the building and move it, because the land on which it stood had been sold. Thankfully, the early society failed to move the building and, through heroic efforts, the property was bought back. Restoration began almost immediately and continues under the watchful eye of the Ezra Meeker Historical Society.
Exterior additions were removed, as were the dropped ceilings, fire doors and partitions from its nursing-home days. Painted woodwork was stripped and restored. In 1972, many layers of paint were removed from the drawing room to reveal the original painted and stenciled ceilings. Thousands of wood screws were needed to stabilize the nearly century-old plaster, which was preserved and repainted to replicate the original colors and patterns.
Over the next 20 years, the original paintings were uncovered, copied and repainted. The identity of the painter remained a mystery until 2000, when research revealed that Frederick Nelson Atwood, an East Coast-trained artist who specialized in decorating theaters, took credit for the work.
Lawrence Kreisman is program director of Historic Seattle and author of "The Arts and Crafts Movement in the Pacific Northwest." Benjamin Benschneider is a Pacific Northwest magazine staff photographer.




















News where, when and how you want it
All newsletters Privacy statement