Originally published Tuesday, May 13, 2008 at 12:00 AM
Horse Racing | Sport is addicted to drugs
If many people concerned about the safety of Thoroughbreds had their way, the Preakness might be a race for 4-year-olds instead of 3-year-olds...
Special to The Washington Post
If many people concerned about the safety of Thoroughbreds had their way, the Preakness might be a race for 4-year-olds instead of 3-year-olds. Saturday's race at Pimlico in Baltimore would be run on a synthetic surface instead of dirt. The jockeys would be forbidden to carry whips.
These are among the proposals put forth since filly Eight Belles broke down shortly after finishing second to Big Brown in the May 3 Kentucky Derby and was euthanized on the track at Churchill Downs.
Even with the second leg of the Triple Crown four days away, the sport is preoccupied with the filly's death and stung by harsh criticism it has taken on the issue of equine safety. The industry knows it has to do something, but what?
One of the most common responses to the breakdown of Eight Belles is the argument the sport places too much stress on undeveloped horses by racing them at age 2 and by subjecting them to the rigors of the Triple Crown events as 3-year-olds. The evidence of two fatalities in the past six Triple Crown races — Kentucky Derby winner Barbaro in the 2006 Preakness and Eight Belles — seems to support this theory.
But top equine veterinarians insist it is a fallacy that Thoroughbreds race at too young an age. Rick Arthur, equine medical director of the California Horse Racing Board, said horses need exertion as 2-year-olds because it develops their bones.
"It's beneficial for that process to occur as the horse goes through the maturation process," he said. "The 3-year-old is a mature horse in terms of his bone development."
The death of Eight Belles also brought calls for more tracks to install synthetic surfaces. Preliminary evidence suggests the rate of fatal accidents is lower on synthetic tracks than on dirt.
Jay Hovdey, Daily Racing Form columnist, last week made a case for synthetics that goes beyond breakdown statistics. One major reason for the fragility of U.S. Thoroughbreds is breeders' obsession with speed; they don't care as much about durability.
This is a seemingly insoluble problem because nobody can legislate decisions of breeders. Many synthetic tracks have proved to be tough for horses on or near the early lead; in some cases, the synthetic tracks have had a distinctly anti-speed bias. If all racetracks adopted synthetic surfaces, Hovdey noted, breeders would have to produce a different type of Thoroughbred.
But a drawback to this vision is that horse racing might not be much of a sport if speed became a liability. The Thoroughbreds who make the game exciting tend to be the brilliant ones such as Big Brown — not the plodders who often win on Polytrack.
Even if synthetic tracks do reduce catastrophic injuries, it is a specious argument to suggest dirt surfaces are the root cause of the safety problem.
There was no perceived epidemic of breakdowns in the United States 30 years ago; dirt tracks seemed to be safe enough. And the rate of breakdowns is not a serious issue in some other nations where racing is conducted on dirt.
![]()
When a series of fatalities marred the 2006 Del Mar meeting, the California Horse Racing Board reacted by mandating tracks replace dirt surfaces with synthetic surfaces.
Perhaps my view is too cynical, but I believe the industry is focusing on this peripheral issue because it can't face up to the real one.
U.S. horses are less durable than they used to be, and they are less durable than their counterparts in other countries. So what makes contemporary U.S. racing different? We all know the one-word answer to that question: drugs.
In the 1970s, American racing adopted a policy of "permissive medication," legalizing drugs that are banned in the rest of the racing world. The administration of the diuretic Lasix and the painkiller Butazolidin became standard at U.S. racetracks. Other commonly used drugs — such as corticosteroids injected in the joints of ailing animals — allow them to run without pain and surely contribute to breakdowns. The use of anabolic steroids puts extra muscle on horses, forcing them to carry more weight.
Eight Belles' trainer, Larry Jones, last week vowed the filly was never on steroids.
The average U.S. horse has made fewer and fewer starts per year since the 1970s, suggesting a vicious cycle: Unsound horses who succeed with the aid of medications go to stud and propagate more unsound horses.
Despite the evidence the U.S. medication policy has been a failure, horsemen have regularly resisted most efforts to curb the use of medications.
American racing is addicted to drugs, and American horses will never again be fueled by hay, oats and water alone.
But until the industry faces the medication issue seriously, its efforts to address equine safety will be misguided.
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
NEW - 10:43 PM
NW Briefs: Seattle Pacific women out in first round of NCAA soccer tournament
Briefs | NHL: Red Wings beat Canucks in Detroit
Razor clam digs look like good bet this weekend
Briefs | Golf: Woods fires 66 to lead Australian Masters
Sideline Chatter: What about the guy who drives the Zamboni?

Video shows violent arrest by SPD
The SPD has opened an internal investigation into the violent arrest of a suspect.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
- Ichiro thrilled that Ken Griffey Jr. is back for another Mariners season
- Man charged with killing police officer is paralyzed
- Seattle 'Jon Doe' shows up in New Mexico with amnesia
- State Democrats facing revolt by labor
- Russell Branyan passes on Mariners' offer
- Huskies sign California prep forward Desmond Simmons
- Capitol Hill's War Room for sale
- The Hot Stone League | Ken Griffey Jr. will be a Mariner in 2010
- Costco Wholesale opens first Manhattan store
- State Democrats facing revolt by labor
490 - Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
262 - Do not slander Islam after Fort Hood
216 - Aggravated murder charge filed against man accused of killing officer
212 - U.S. envoy in Kabul isn't sold on adding to forces
124 - Salute those Muslim-Americans who stand up for their country
116 - Lou Dobbs says he is leaving CNN
96 - Obama announces summit in December on finding jobs
59 - City Light rate increase of 13.8 percent proposed
54 - Scouting Oregon State
50
- Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
- Ichiro thrilled that Ken Griffey Jr. is back for another Mariners season
- Costco Wholesale opens first Manhattan store
- State Democrats facing revolt by labor
- Chefs offer holiday recipes and preparation tips
- The Hot Stone League | Ken Griffey Jr. will be a Mariner in 2010
- Ski areas opening early, here and B.C.
- Kayak on Kitsap Peninsula's Miller Bay to get friendly with the chum (salmon)
- Capitol Hill's War Room for sale
- Evergreen Bank given a deadline to fix capital shortage








