Originally published Tuesday, December 2, 2008 at 4:54 PM
Comments (10)
E-mail article
Print view
U.S. automakers' plan should include a return to romance
Once the Big Three United States auto companies restructure and have better technology in place, they can turn to winning back the American public.
Syndicated columnist
The American "love affair" with cars is close to dead, then-Ford Motor chief Bill Ford lamented six years ago. "In California, people used to write songs about T-Birds and Corvettes," said Henry Ford's great-grandson. "Today, they write regulations." Ford had earlier shocked Detroit by admitting that sport-utility vehicles caused environmental problems.
Ford got it, even before the recent spike in gasoline prices sent consumers stampeding out of gas-guzzlers. As the Big Three automakers again ask Washington for help, Ford Motor is the only one not begging for an immediate taxpayer bailout. One reason: It's the farthest along in developing fuel-efficient vehicles.
Once the companies restructure and have the technology in place, they can turn to winning back the public. A car isn't like a refrigerator. You buy a fridge, and if the appliance works, it quickly fades into the wallpaper. A car is your steed and daily companion. It develops a personality, even if only in your head.
And what kind of personality has Detroit offered in recent decades? Often not a pleasing one. A half-century has passed since ads promoted the 1957 Chevy Bel Air as "Kitten-Quiet and Cream-Smooth." Gone are the automotive hymns of the '60s — the Beach Boys' "Little Deuce Coupe" or Jan and Dean's "Surf City." Would Bruce Springsteen ever serenade an SUV (or its owner) as he did the pastel Caddie in his 1984 rockabilly song "Pink Cadillac"?
A moment of silence for the female curves and rocket ship fins that made Detroit's golden age so much fun. At some point, cars designed to seduce turned into trucks of potential aggression — humorless, muscle-bound brutes. The SUV was old technology sold at big markups in a market dependent on cheap gas.
Detroit lost hearts and minds. Environmentalists raged at its killing of rules to cut smog and emissions of planet-warming gases. National-security experts decried its promotion of a gas-guzzling culture that enriched our oil-producing enemies. While General Motors fought fuel-efficiency regulations, Toyota successfully marketed itself as the Earth-loving maker of the Prius.
Yes, Detroit had to think short-term if it was to maintain its very generous employee and retiree benefits, some of which were excessive. (Even friends of labor strain to justify paying laid-off autoworkers $31 an hour plus benefits to do nothing.) The United Auto Workers are not to blame, though. They tried to get what they could. The carmakers should have drawn lines.
Thus, when the Big Three went to Washington last month for their bailout, they met a Congress that was not so much lame duck as mad duck. Imagine Donald Duck's nephews Huey, Dewey and Louie flying their private jets to ask Uncle Scrooge McDuck for a handout.
Note that President-elect Barack Obama and the enhanced Democratic majority in Congress are not rushing forth with alms.
"Taxpayers can't be expected to pony up more money for an auto industry that has been resistant to change," Obama said after the three executives were sent home empty-handed. "And I was surprised that they did not have a better-though-out proposal when they arrived in Congress."
Uncle Scrooge couldn't have said it better.
Detroit's plan should include a return to romance. Picture an ad with a cowboy. He's leaning against a big-tailed 1957 DeSoto Fireflite in "Fiesta Red" with white trim. "Choose any car in the De Soto corral, and pardner," the cowboy says, "you've got yourself a thoroughbred."
Nothing wrong with plain, reliable cars, but surely Detroit can market something sexier than the appliances produced by Honda and Toyota. There may be a song in it.
Providence Journal columnist Froma Harrop's column appears regularly on editorial pages of The Times. Her e-mail address is fharrop@projo.com
2008, The Providence Journal Co.
David S. Broder / Syndicated columnist: Lessons learned in '94 could be valuable to Congress
UPDATE - 2:05 PM
Froma Harrop / Syndicated columnist: Will Snowe fall in Maine?
Guest columnist: Act soon to keep residents, workers and employees safe in downtown Seattle
David Brooks / Syndicated columnist: Building trust from ground up
nwautos
Porsche 911 GT3 RS hybrid (Associated Press) Porsche flywheel Porsche debuted its 911 GT3 RS hybrid, which uses a flywheel rather than batteries to st...
Post a comment
nwjobs
Post a comment
Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
Make profits, not meetings
Post a comment
- Washington men rout New Mexico, reach Sweet 16
- Husky Men's Basketball Blog | New Mexico game thread
- Missing boy's death ruled an accidental drowning
- 'Bizarre' tanker twist: Russians will bid against Boeing for Air Force contract
- Preview: Washington vs. New Mexico
- Mariners Blog | Reds 6, Mariners 2: Don Wakamatsu rips umpire over Milton Bradley "witch hunt"
- Steve Kelley | Why can't the Huskies continue this run? | Steve Kelley
- Teacher killed by wolves leaves vivid blog of Alaska wilderness
- Judge weighs Ballard 'missing link' to Burke-Gilman Trail
- State Senate passes tax package, remains at odds with House on sales tax
- New Mexico game thread
463 - Health-insurance subsidies prompt questions of affordability
195 - Russian company will bid on Air Force tanker
122 - Obama making final health care pitch to House Dems
119 - State Senate passes tax package, remains at odds with House on sales tax
119 - Sunday's vote on health care still a cliffhanger
91 - Washington men rout New Mexico, reach Sweet 16
89 - Adam Smith backs health bill; Baird still undecided
51 - So which team are you taking - UW or New Mexico?
45 - Sweeeet!
44
- 'Bizarre' tanker twist: Russians will bid against Boeing for Air Force contract
- California tribe on spiritual quest to bring salmon home
- An abundance of free Wi-Fi across the Northwest
- Lawsuit claims Boy Scouts has hidden extensive documents about sexual abuse
- Northwest Living | Island cottage sails on wings of steel and glass
- Walgreens: no new Medicaid patients as of April 16
- All You Can Eat | Won't you take me to, Nettletown -- now open on Eastlake
- Call to readers: Enter now, or forever hold your Peeps
- Is raw, unpasteurized milk safe?
- Steve Kelley | Washington coach Lorenzo Romar wins his way






