Originally published August 4, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified August 17, 2007 at 4:18 PM
The Reader's View
History's blueprint
Recent moves to honor a number of Seattle's buildings with historical designation have drawn out a regressive streak in a city prideful...
Special to The Times
Today, the stories of a building
Recent moves to honor a number of Seattle's buildings with historical designation have drawn out a regressive streak in a city prideful of its progressive, world-class status ["38 properties eyed as historic," Times, Local News, July 12, "Let's not get hysterical about historic preservation," Lynne K. Varner editorial column, July 18, and "The landmark you save belongs to someone else," Bruce Ramsey editorial column, July 25].Sadly, some have expressed contempt for expanding the city's list of landmark properties, stating that only a rarefied sample of historic buildings should be preserved.
Setting an arbitrary standard for preserving historic buildings is elitist decision-making about what is important and meaningful about our past. It also denies us the opportunity to be fully educated about who and what have imprinted our landscapes. Property ownership is temporary; history is not.
Real history is about complete disclosure, and the past is captured in many formats — high-style, aesthetic buildings being only one.
Modest buildings have stories too, and sometimes those stories are greater than their bricks and mortar. Even esteemed historic places hundreds of years old can be humble.
Examine a piazza in Italy and you begin to see that the individual pieces are often remarkably common. But assembled as a whole, these buildings create remarkable and vibrant envelopes where modern people work and play, and the tourism dollars they draw have built robust economies. Many Americans — and it appears, some in Seattle — lack this ability to coexist with the past.
A mere sprinkling of historic oddities throughout a landscape of transient modern buildings is not historic preservation, nor is it good stewardship of our heritage. Those who would sieve out what they believe to be "lesser" buildings will leave us with a weak and incomplete record of Seattle's rich history.
Future generations deserve more than this selective view of how our cities originated and who contributed to the larger story.
A city that touts diversity, tolerance and environmental sustainability should extend those same principles to its curation of history as reflected in the built environment.
Historic buildings are diverse by nature. Some project high drama and ornate fabric, others tell their stories in modest clothes. Some are ordinary, and the history they embody sometimes unglamorous or unpleasant. But isn't that the point if you want to be honest about your past?
No historic preservationist believes that every older structure can or should be saved, but don't we owe the future a balanced accounting of the past and the forces and ideals that have shaped it?
Lauren McCroskey of Auburn is chair of the King County Landmarks Commission.
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
NEW - 03:47 PM
Lance Dickie / Seattle Times editorial columnist: GOP clueless as families struggle with health care
E.J. Dionne / Syndicated columnist: Abortion fight shouldn't undermine health-care reform
NEW - 03:35 PM
Nicholas D. Kristof / Syndicated Columnist: America's defining choice: war in Afghanistan or health care at home
NEW - 03:47 PM
Ellen Goodman / Syndicated columnist: Health-care reform or reproductive rights: a false choice
NEW - 03:35 PM
Guest columnist: Save sexual-assault center's funding to help girls like me
Video shows violent arrest by SPD
The SPD has opened an internal investigation into the violent arrest of a suspect.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
- Ichiro thrilled that Ken Griffey Jr. is back for another Mariners season
- Man charged with killing police officer is paralyzed
- Seattle 'Jon Doe' shows up in New Mexico with amnesia
- State Democrats facing revolt by labor
- Russell Branyan passes on Mariners' offer
- Huskies sign California prep forward Desmond Simmons
- Capitol Hill's War Room for sale
- The Hot Stone League | Ken Griffey Jr. will be a Mariner in 2010
- Costco Wholesale opens first Manhattan store
- State Democrats facing revolt by labor
490 - Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
262 - Do not slander Islam after Fort Hood
216 - Aggravated murder charge filed against man accused of killing officer
214 - U.S. envoy in Kabul isn't sold on adding to forces
124 - Salute those Muslim-Americans who stand up for their country
116 - Lou Dobbs says he is leaving CNN
96 - Obama announces summit in December on finding jobs
59 - City Light rate increase of 13.8 percent proposed
54 - Scouting Oregon State
50
- Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
- Ichiro thrilled that Ken Griffey Jr. is back for another Mariners season
- Costco Wholesale opens first Manhattan store
- State Democrats facing revolt by labor
- Chefs offer holiday recipes and preparation tips
- The Hot Stone League | Ken Griffey Jr. will be a Mariner in 2010
- Ski areas opening early, here and B.C.
- Kayak on Kitsap Peninsula's Miller Bay to get friendly with the chum (salmon)
- Capitol Hill's War Room for sale
- Evergreen Bank given a deadline to fix capital shortage





