Originally published Monday, February 12, 2007 at 12:00 AM
Froma Harrop / Syndicated columnist
Why begrudge workers a little "pin money"?
One thing about this minimum-wage debate truly fries me. It's the idea that the minimum does not have to be raised because...
One thing about this minimum-wage debate truly fries me. It's the idea that the minimum does not have to be raised because the people who get it don't need the money.
"Many, maybe most, of the gainers from a higher minimum wage are not poor," Nobel economist Gary Becker and U.S. Appeals Court Judge Richard Posner write. As examples, they cite retirees who want to get out of the house "and earn pin money."
On PBS, a businessman in Clarkston, Wash., explains that the servers making minimum at his pizza place aren't adults supporting families but kids who want to go home and "play video games."
There is a conservative worldview that people who don't make serious money aren't serious people. Economic incentives are for entrepreneurs. For the low-of-wage, you put a bowl of nuggets on the ground and pat their heads.
First off, it's not true that minimum-wage earners are overwhelmingly in it for the fun. The average such worker brings home more than half the family's weekly earnings, according to an analysis by the Economic Policy Institute. And 9 percent of the beneficiaries of a minimum-wage hike would be single parents.
But let's assume for the sake of argument that the majority of minimum-wage earners regard their paychecks as mad money. What of it? The minimum wage puts a dignified floor under what a worker's time is worth. Whether people use that money to play the slots or pay a dentist is nobody's business but theirs. By the way, if the high-school waitress is covering the family's rent, does that mean she gets a raise?
I've not heard of a single case in which a board of directors delved into an executive's spending plans before setting compensation. Imagine their saying: "Our CEO has a house in Palm Beach and a ranch outside Aspen. If we give him an extra $5 million, he'd probably just blow it on another jet. Nope, he doesn't need it."
The Senate and the House have both passed bills to raise the federal minimum wage from $5.15 to $7.25 an hour over two years, but conservatives attached a pile of small-business tax breaks to the Senate version. House Ways and Means Chair Charlie Rangel had insisted on a "clean bill" but now says he'll negotiate.
Many conservatives like to both baby and worship the small-businessperson. They are especially fond of sob stories about how a raise in the minimum will drive a mom-and-pop business into bankruptcy. Odd, but businesses seem to cope with increases in electricity rates, property taxes and the price of materials. Where is it written that wages can't go up? The minimum hasn't budged in 10 years.
If business owners can't make a decent profit paying their workers a minimum wage — that adjusted for inflation would still be lower than it was in 1969 — then perhaps, just perhaps, they shouldn't be in business.
In the conservative songbook, however, never is heard a discouraging word about the heroics of the small-businessperson. It's always some government regulation that's tripping them up — never that they took on too much debt, their burgers aren't as good as another guy's or they're selling the wrong thing.
Raising the minimum is good politics, and so you do have Republicans from blue-collar districts, like Rep. Phil English of Western Pennsylvania, signing on. That's laudable, but then English gets onto C-SPAN and says we should also acknowledge that "raising the minimum wage does not create wealth."
According to this perspective, creating wealth means funneling $2 million into an executive's pocket — not an extra two bucks-an-hour into a dishwasher's. Makes me nuts.
Providence Journal columnist Froma Harrop's column appears regularly on editorial pages of The Times. Her e-mail address is fharrop@projo.com
2007, The Providence Journal Co.
NEW - 03:17 PM
E.J. Dionne / Syndicated columnist: Obama's 'third way' in Afghanistan: neither Iraq nor Vietnam
NEW - 03:17 PM
Guest columnist: Turning to a new chapter in Afghanistan
Leonard Pitts Jr. / Syndicated columnist: New York terror trials will restore faith in rule of law
Neal Peirce / Syndicated columnist: It's time to promote development that conserves land and energy
Guest columnist: Ringing the alarm about a threat to homeless youth
Real Salt Lake wins MLS Cup
Real Salt Lake defeated the Los Angeles Galaxy with penalty kicks after 120 minutes of play at Qwest Field in Seattle.
general classifieds
Garage & estate salesFurniture & home furnishings
Sporting goods
just listed
42" Hitachi Plasma 1080i - $500
8 Drawer Dresser with Attached Mirror - $200
8 seat pecon formal dining table and china hutch - $1500
More listings
POST A FREE LISTING
shopping
Give yourself a treat and visit Watson Kennedy's Holiday Open Houses
More minding the store
events for Monday, Nov. 23
- Castle Discount with Military ID
- CraftsGiving
- Alhambra 20 Percent Off Jewelry Sale
- Dish It Up! Totally Truffles
editors' picks
- Phinney Ridge & Greenwood shopping
- Independent video stores
- Pioneer Square shopping
- Garden furnishings
- 'The Road' takes Viggo Mortensen to Mount St. Helens and Astoria, Ore.
- Tugboat sinks at Seattle waterfront pier
- Illegal workers quietly let go
- Child-support error costs nearly $21,000
- Vikings easily beat the Seahawks
- Craigslist adoption ad: A plea by young mother-to-be? A scam?
- Chase shrugs off loss of CD investors
- Woman stabbed by stranger in North Seattle
- Snow piles up on Cascade slopes
- Denny Triangle gains skyline, but tenants slow to come
- Illegal workers quietly let go
373 - Climate change speeds up since 1997 Kyoto accord
210 - Metro won't cut bus service after all
151 - New Husky recruit: Enes Kanter
97 - Historic health care bill clears Senate hurdle
95 - Tattoos at Mill Creek Church pierce skin, soul
83 - Middleton says Huskies "plan on scoring at least 50 points'' Saturday
82 - Jerry Brewer: Seahawks can't lean on the Hutch Crutch now
74 - UW, WSU once again meet to see who's worse
68 - Seattle woman charged with knife attack on boyfriend's ex
65
- Sprouts, raw fish on attorney's 'do not eat' list
- Tattoos at Mill Creek church pierce skin, soul
- Food-safety lawyer's wish: Put me out of business
- Illegal workers quietly let go
- Architects, chefs find 'kid' within to build Gingerbread Village
- Rediscovering Moab, 'the most beautiful place on Earth'
- It's possible to recover a life lost to hoarding
- Child-support error costs nearly $21,000
- 'The Road' takes Viggo Mortensen to Mount St. Helens and Astoria, Ore.
- Taste | The Great Pie Bake-off pits friends and fruit




