Originally published November 22, 2009 at 12:15 AM | Page modified November 27, 2009 at 12:44 PM
Comments (0)
E-mail article
Print
Share
Nicole Brodeur
You have more to spare than you think you do
You would expect a rabbi to refer to the holiest of tomes when asked why we should give to those in need.
![]() |
Seattle Times staff columnist
You would expect a rabbi to refer to the holiest of tomes when asked why we should give to those in need.
But not Rabbi Yohanna Kinberg. She went straight to the "Seinfeld" archives.
In an episode called "The Stall," Elaine was in the ladies room when she discovered she had no toilet paper. She asked the woman in the adjoining stall to help her out.
"No, I don't have a square to spare," the woman told her. "I can't spare a square."
Kinberg, of the Temple B'nai Torah in Bellevue, thinks there's a sobering thought behind the humor — so much so that she used the episode in a recent sermon.
"The Seinfeld characters are completely neurotic and greedy," she told me. "But if everyone acts like that, then we have a really impoverished society."
It's something to think about as we kick off The Seattle Times Fund For The Needy.
None of us really feels like we can spare a square — and we all have our reasons. Financial worries brought on by layoffs and furloughs, stock drops and cost increases.
But if we don't give to others, we miss out on being a part of something big, Kinberg said.
And we lose the chance to see that while we may have given something away, we still have so much left. An abundance, really.
She's right; The Fund For The Needy had one of its biggest years ever in 2008 — a time when we were bailing out the Big Three automakers, blasting Bernie Madoff and feeling flat about the future.
So what is behind the psychology of giving?
![]()
"Feeling affluent or feeling impoverished is a state of mind," Kinberg believes. "You want to see the world from a place of abundance as opposed to adversity or want."
It also helps to consider the faces behind the agencies that the Fund will benefit — faces we'll be featuring in stories throughout the season.
Peter Singer, the Ira W. DeCamp professor of bioethics at Princeton University, believes that people are more inclined to give when they can put a face to what they're being asked to fund.
"They are more likely to respond to a request to help an individual, rather than a large number of people," said Singer, the author of "The Life You Can Save."
Say you're walking by a pond and see a small child fall in, apparently in danger of drowning, Singer says. The child is unattended. Of course you would rush into the water to save the child without even stopping to take off your expensive shoes. Right?
It's the same thing with giving to those in need. Aren't their lives worth more than your spendy shoes? A latte? Cable?
Singer directed me to www.thelifeyoucansave.com, where people can calculate how much they should spare.
"What do we get out of it?" Singer asked. "Well, I suppose we get some sort of warm glow, knowing we could help. Our lives become more meaningful."
Kinberg understands the pressure we're all under. If you've ever written a check to a charity, you're likely being bombarded right now.
"There is a lot of stress."
So when choosing where to give, Kinberg said, prioritize.
The rabbi gives to homeless women, and charities that help older people and children — the most vulnerable, in her view.
Find your own priority in our stories, and give what you can with those faces in mind.
"We may feel impoverished because we lost stocks or our hours have been cut," Kinberg said. "But we can still put food on the table."
We can certainly spare a square.
Nicole Brodeur's column appears Tuesday and Friday. Reach her at 206-464-2334 or nbrodeur@seattletimes.com.
Even a Junior Mint or two.
UPDATE - 8:10 PM
Nicole Brodeur: Possibilities replace prisoners in island's future
Nicole Brodeur: She never lost moral compass
More Nicole Brodeur headlines...
My column is more a conversation with readers than a spouting of my own views. I like to think that, in writing, I lay down a bridge between readers and me. It is as much their space as mine. And it is a place to tell the stories that, otherwise, may not get into the paper.
nbrodeur@seattletimes.com | 206-464-2334

Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
nwautos
GM's "Happy Grad" 2012 Super Bowl ad. (General Motors) GM cuts Super Bowl from its ad budget General Motors says it won't run ads during the next Supe...
Post a comment
- Madrona dad killed by a bullet as he drove through Central Area
- Some costs going up Friday as private retailers take over liquor sales
- Man wounded in shooting at Folklife fest
- Seattle police twice face hostile crowds at scenes of violent crime
- Brandon League looks out of his own for Mariners
- Juror alternates' actions have court on red alert
- Vatican in chaos after butler arrested for leaks
- Upset neighbors say Kirkland condo project is too big
- Which Seattle restaurant is on "America's Most Expensive" list? | All You Can Eat
- Random killing of motorist stirs prayers, reflection
- Madrona dad killed by stray bullet as he drove through Central Area
524 - M's-Angels game thread, May 26
365 - Some costs going up Friday as private retailers take over liquor sales
292 - Traffic study gives arena a green light; critics see red
274 - Seattle police twice face hostile crowds at scenes of violence crime
187 - A worthwhile conversation about charter schools
162 - Man wounded at Folklife fest The gunman fled into the Seattle Center crowd, but an officer gave chase, and police reported making an arrest and recovering a gun.
82 - Shooting victim a dad just like me
69 - Random killing of motorist stirs prayers, reflection
59 - Angels slam Mariners for third consecutive game
45
- Madrona dad killed by a bullet as he drove through Central Area
- Some costs going up Friday as private retailers take over liquor sales
- Meet the biologist who is salmon farming's worst enemy
- A second chance for idle electronics
- Shooting victim a dad just like me | Danny Westneat
- Wash. fish farm kills stock after virus found
- Which Seattle restaurant is on "America's Most Expensive" list? | All You Can Eat
- Tacoma's LeMay car museum honors the American automobile
- 'Tutankhamun' in Seattle: artifacts both dazzling and humble | Art review
- A lost Seattle climber's family seeks an elusive peace








