Originally published May 20, 2008 at 12:00 AM | Page modified May 20, 2008 at 5:13 PM
Supreme Court rules e-mail soliciting of child porn illegal
The Supreme Court gave prosecutors a powerful tool Monday to attack the spread of child pornography online, ruling that people who send...
Los Angeles Times
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court gave prosecutors a powerful tool Monday to attack the spread of child pornography online, ruling that people who send messages over a computer offering or seeking sexual images of children can be sent to prison, even when no such pornography exists.
The 7-2 ruling, which upheld a five-year-old law, rejected the claim that such messages are protected as free speech.
"This will be a big help," said Patrick Trueman, a Virginia lawyer who led the U.S. Justice Department's anti-obscenity unit during the Reagan and George H.W. Bush administrations. "You don't have to prove the underlying material is illegal. The criminal offense is the speech that offers to sell or trade in illegal material."
Monday's ruling goes a long way toward overturning the effect of a 2002 decision that shielded computer-generated pornography. The justices said then that because no real children were involved in producing these images, this material deserved protection as a form of free speech.
Prosecutors then faced a practical problem. How could they prove that realistic images of child-sex scenes involved actual children? Defendants could assert they were "virtual" pornography.
In response, Congress passed a law in 2003 making it a crime to exchange online messages about "any material or purported material" that would cause "another to believe" it depicts a minor engaged in sex, whether "actual or simulated." Violations call for at least five years and as many as 20 years in prison.
The fate of this law remained in doubt until Monday because of legal challenges. Two years ago, a U.S. appeals court in Atlanta ruled the law unconstitutional because it was overly broad. It could apply, in theory, to a grandfather who sends an e-mail entitled "Good pics of kids in bed" to describe a photo of sleeping toddlers, the appellate judges said. Other critics said the law could ensnare people who tout a Hollywood movie that contains simulated sex scenes.
In Monday's opinion, the Supreme Court dismissed those objections as "fanciful hypotheticals" and upheld the law.
"Child pornography harms and debases the most defenseless of our citizens," Justice Antonin Scalia said. "We hold that offers to provide or requests to obtain child pornography are categorically excluded from the First Amendment."
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
UPDATE - 09:52 PM
Sources: Obama near decision on Afghanistan troops
Abortion could roil Senate health care debate
Troops in Afghanistan fight swine flu amid war
Investigators say Fort Hood suspect acted alone
Salvadoran town hit by landslide buries dead

Medal of Honor
Bruce Crandall and John "Bud" Hawk of Kitsap County say no one "wins" the Medal of Honor. The two recipients of the medal explain they weren't trying to be heroes - just do their duty.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- 'Missing' SeaTac man found with new name, in new state
- Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
- Police: DNA from officer's slaying matches suspect
- How an underdog named Mike McGinn took City Hall
- 3 Cascade Mountain passes close due to snow; more rain, wind expected Sunday
- Prosecutors consider charges against suspect in police shooting
- Three more fires ignite in Greenwood
- Steve Kelley | Hasselbeck gives Seahawks' sagging season a stay of execution
- The birth of 'Grunge,' in photos by Michael Lavine
- Teenage serial burglar suspected in more Camano Island burglaries
- House health bill unacceptable to many in Senate
246 - Prosecutors prepare charges against suspect in police shooting
216 - Pelosi tours Seattle's Swedish after health-care vote
158 - Prosecutors prepare charges against suspect in police shooting
138 - Alleged shooter tied to mosque of 9/11 hijackers
135 - Obama puts heat on Senate to speed health bill
123 - Resolute Fort Hood soldiers ready for return
108 - McGinn more than doubles his lead over Mallahan
94 - Ayn Rand: goddess of the market, gateway to the American right
79 - Cutaia says replay handled properly on Austin TD
66
- For 80-year-old Maple Valley man, hoops aren't just a dream
- Plans call for Triangle to become West Seattle gateway
- 10 ways to take control of your health
- Three more fires ignite in Greenwood
- The birth of 'Grunge,' in photos by Michael Lavine
- 'Missing' SeaTac man found with new name, in new state
- Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
- Taste | Ruth Reichl still reigns as queen of America's culinary scene
- Silver Lake restaurant destroyed by fire
- Pakistani-American cafe, bar owner on verge of being Granite Falls mayor





