Tuesday, October 2, 2007 - Page updated at 01:03 AM
E-mail article
Print view Share:
Digg
Newsvine
Judge says Bush order on records goes too far
WASHINGTON — Presidents don't have indefinite veto power over which records are made public after they've left office, a federal judge ruled Monday.
In a narrowly crafted ruling, U.S. District Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly invalidated part of President Bush's 2001 executive order, which allowed former presidents and vice presidents to review executive records before they are released under the Freedom of Information Act.
By law, the National Archives has the final say over the release of presidential records and Kollar-Kotelly ruled that Bush's executive order "effectively eliminates" that discretion. It allows former presidents to delay the release of records "presumably indefinitely," she said.
The judge ordered the National Archives not to withhold any more documents based on that section of the executive order.
The ruling was made in a lawsuit filed by the American Historical Association and other organizations, which argued that Bush's Executive Order 13,233 was an "impermissible exercise of the executive power."
The judge dismissed most of the claims and sidestepped some of the loftier questions, such as whether the entire order was unconstitutional or whether former presidents can claim executive privilege as grounds for withholding documents.
Spokeswoman Emily Lawrimore said the White House was reviewing the opinion and considering its options.
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company

Close-up: Big 3 make fuel-efficient return
Priceless gift to disadvantaged: Attending inauguration
Solar car shines at climate conference
Jewish settlers ousted from disputed house
- USC's Steve Sarkisian is added to Washington's coach list
- Huskies set to hire Steve Sarkisian, according to report, sources
- Fox shows Olympia sign; calls come pouring in
- List grows; 9 Seattle schools could be cut
- Woman swept to sea during marriage proposal
- Jerry Brewer | Big-time coaches won't come running to big-trouble UW
- Michelle Obama's family: From slavery to White House
- Baby dies sleeping in car with parents in Lakewood
- King County home prices fall 9.2% in November
- Beaten toddler in coma; mother's boyfriend to be charged
- Michelle Obama's family: From slavery to White House
- Ancient pot stash found in China
- Washington banks trail industry in key indicators
- No woman is an island — unless she's on San Juan, offseason
- List grows; 9 Seattle schools could be cut
- Woman swept to sea during marriage proposal
- King County home prices fall 9.2% in November
- Finding vacation rentals - and offseason bargains
- Huskies set to hire Steve Sarkisian, according to report, sources
- Port of Seattle probe exposes fraud, a "get-it-done culture"