Originally published June 5, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified June 5, 2007 at 2:01 AM
Impromptu expletives OK, federal court says
In a victory for TV networks but a setback for efforts to shield children from coarse language, a federal court ruled Monday that broadcasters...
Los Angeles Times
WASHINGTON — In a victory for TV networks but a setback for efforts to shield children from coarse language, a federal court ruled Monday that broadcasters cannot be penalized for expletives that are considered impromptu.
The appeals judges in New York repudiated the Federal Communications Commissions' recent crackdown on broadcast indecency, calling its efforts "arbitrary and capricious."
TV networks long have complained that enforcement of the rules is inconsistent and unpredictable. Although the court's 2-1 decision sent the issue back to the FCC for rethinking, the strong rebuke prompted some advocacy groups and lawmakers to urge the agency to appeal to the Supreme Court.
"We are very pleased with the court's decision and continue to believe that government regulation of content serves no purpose other than to chill artistic expression in violation of the First Amendment," Fox Broadcasting said in a statement.
The case specifically involved two Fox broadcasts, and other networks joined in the lawsuit.
At issue has been a series of unscripted obscenities uttered in recent years by such performers as Bono, Cher and Nicole Richie during live awards shows. Networks argued they shouldn't be punished when an expletive slips through their safeguards.
Broadcasters have felt increasingly under siege after the exposure of singer Janet Jackson's right breast during the live halftime show of the 2004 Super Bowl, which CBS executives claimed caught them off guard. The resulting firestorm helped prompt Congress last year to approve a tenfold increase in fines that boosts the maximum penalty for a violation to $325,000.
But while broadcasters and Hollywood unions cheered the 2-1 decision by the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, FCC Chairman Kevin Martin blasted it.
"I view this as having a significant impact on our ability to enforce our indecency regime as to any restrictions on language," he said.
Martin defended the policy and said FCC attorneys soon would decide whether to appeal. The FCC could ask the entire 2nd Circuit to reconsider or go directly to the Supreme Court.
Commissioner Michael Copps, another strong opponent of broadcast indecency, promised a fight.
"So any broadcaster who sees this decision as a green light to send more gratuitous sex and violence into our homes would be making a huge mistake," Copps said in a written statement.
![]()
A network executive who requested anonymity said broadcasters still would use delays to try to bleep out expletives.
"It just means on the rare occasions where we might make a mistake or error despite our best efforts, it's going to be harder for the commission to cite that as indecency," the executive said.
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
A Bing deal for Microsoft, News Corp.?
Amazon, Wal-Mart escalate Web price war
6.8-magnitude quake rattles Tonga
8 charged in probe of terrorism-recruiting network in U.S.
Hate crimes against gays, religious groups up, FBI says

New Beginnings Christian Fellowship
Coming in this Sunday's Pacific Northwest Magazine: Pastor Braxton's mission is to preach a message that appeals to everyone.
nwautos
Local riders say they've seen a surge in scooter interest in recent years, mostly from people wanting another commuting option. Seattle now ranks as o...
Post a comment
nwjobs
Post a comment
Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
Do you suffer from "sitting disease"?
Post a comment
- Illegal workers quietly let go
- Sprouts, raw fish on attorney's 'do not eat' list
- Jerry Brewer | Jerry Brewer: Seahawks can't lean on the Hutch Crutch now
- Woman stabbed by stranger in North Seattle
- Tattoos at Mill Creek church pierce skin, soul
- UW, WSU once again meet to see who's worse
- Food-safety lawyer's wish: Put me out of business
- Husky Football Blog | Ranking the Pac
- Vikings easily beat the Seahawks
- Tugboat sinks at Seattle waterfront pier
- Illegal workers quietly let go
425 - Climate change speeds up since 1997 Kyoto accord
224 - Bellevue residents blast new bikini espresso stand
179 - Washington State coach Paul Wulff says he's excited about Cougars' future
111 - New Husky recruit: Enes Kanter
109 - Big demand, grim outlook for state Basic Health Plan
107 - Next Seahawks GM should be Mike Holmgren
104 - Seattle woman charged with knife attack on boyfriend's ex
94 - Middleton says Huskies "plan on scoring at least 50 points'' Saturday
87 - Jose Lopez appears to be on his way out
83
- Sprouts, raw fish on attorney's 'do not eat' list
- Tattoos at Mill Creek church pierce skin, soul
- Food-safety lawyer's wish: Put me out of business
- Illegal workers quietly let go
- Architects, chefs find 'kid' within to build Gingerbread Village
- Nicole Brodeur | Homeless woman bent on giving
- Rediscovering Moab, 'the most beautiful place on Earth'
- UW, WSU once again meet to see who's worse
- Hutch gets $10M from Bezos family for immunotherapy research
- Elton John & Billy Joel reschedule Seattle concerts





