Originally published May 9, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified May 9, 2007 at 2:02 AM
"Preventive paradigm" questioned
The strategy to aggressively intervene early with any suspected terror plot, no matter how small, has sometimes resulted in prosecutions...
The Philadelphia Inquirer
Wary of a number of federal anti-terror cases that proved to be overblown, two legal experts Tuesday cautioned about attaching too much significance to the arrest of six Muslims for plotting to attack Fort Dix.
The strategy to aggressively intervene early with any suspected terror plot, no matter how small, has sometimes resulted in prosecutions that failed to live up to their initial billing.
"The fact is that most of those arrested [in the past] are small fry and wannabes," said Daniel Benjamin, a terrorism expert and a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington.
The New Jersey case, in which the suspects trained with paintball guns, bears some resemblance to a 2003 Virginia case in which 11 Muslim men from the Washington area were charged with participating in paramilitary training — including playing paintball — to prepare for "holy war" abroad.
A 26-page indictment unsealed Tuesday indicates that the New Jersey group had no rigorous military training and did not appear close to being able to pull off an attack. The arrests in the case began Monday night after two defendants arrived at a home to buy assault weapons, which had been supplied and disabled by the FBI, officials said.
Some say the government's "preventive paradigm" calling upon law enforcement to intervene early yields symbolic victories, but in the long run, may be counterproductive.
David Cole, a Georgetown University law professor, said prosecutors are under pressure to bring cases quickly. "But there's a risk of losing valuable intelligence if a case is prosecuted too early, as well as assembling a weak case against a real security threat — the risk of losing a serious case," he said.
Civil-liberties experts also said the use of paid confidential informants can send up a red flag.
Sheik Abdel-Rahman, the blind Egyptian cleric, was convicted of conspiring to bomb the World Trade Center in 1993 largely because of testimony from an informant. But informants, motivated by a paycheck, have also been shown to pressure small players into committing crimes.
The FBI paid an informant $230,000 to infiltrate a Lodi, Calif., mosque to target two Muslim clerics. The clerics were deported, and a Pakistani immigrant and his American-born son were charged in 2005 for lying to the FBI about the younger man's training at a jihadist camp in Pakistan.
Testimony showed that Hamid Hayat, 23, had undergone the training largely at the goading of the informant. He was convicted and is seeking a new trial. The father was acquitted, but later pleaded guilty to lying to a customs agent about trying to carry $28,000 into Pakistan.
Information from The Washington Post is included in this report.
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
UPDATE - 03:21 PM
DC sniper's Muhammad's execution set for tonight
UPDATE - 03:43 PM
Obama salutes Fort Hood victims, promises justice
UPDATE - 03:21 PM
North, South Korea clash at sea before Obama visit
UPDATE - 02:20 PM
Navajo Code Talkers break silence for Veterans Day
UPDATE - 02:20 PM
Ida weakens to a depression, soaks the Southeast

Ken Auletta talks about "Googled"
Ken Auletta talks about Google with Brier Dudley at the Seattle Central Library.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- 'Missing' SeaTac man found with new name, in new state
- Police: DNA from officer's slaying matches suspect
- Lt. governor's son shot by co-worker in Kent; gunman then shot self
- DNA, ballistics tie man to cop killing, police say
- McGinn next Seattle mayor; Mallahan concedes as vote gap widens
- Prosecutors consider charges against suspect in police shooting
- Three more fires ignite in Greenwood
- Trucker dies as big-rig plummets off SF bridge
- Huskies are finding talent in Tacoma
- Steve Kelley | Hasselbeck gives Seahawks' sagging season a stay of execution
- Prosecutors prepare charges against suspect in police shooting
264 - King County OKs 'don't ask' law on immigration
255 - Pelosi tours Seattle's Swedish after health-care vote
210 - McGinn more than doubles his lead over Mallahan
194 - Resolute Fort Hood soldiers ready for return
131 - Obama pressed into role as national healer
131 - Time to bring Ken Griffey Jr. back in 2010
100 - 'Missing' SeaTac man found with new name, in new state
97 - Josh Smith picks UCLA
85 - DNA, ballistics tie man to cop killing, police say
85
- For 80-year-old Maple Valley man, hoops aren't just a dream
- Plans call for Triangle to become West Seattle gateway
- 'Missing' SeaTac man found with new name, in new state
- Three more fires ignite in Greenwood
- Silver Lake restaurant destroyed by fire
- Pakistani-American cafe, bar owner on verge of being Granite Falls mayor
- All You Can Eat | Fruit flies: thrill to the kill
- House Speaker Nancy Pelosi tours Seattle's Swedish after health-care vote
- McGinn next Seattle mayor; Mallahan concedes as vote gap widens
- Rainier Pacific Financial calls rescue 'unlikely'





