Originally published April 29, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified April 29, 2007 at 2:03 AM
Inaccurate statistics cited in abstinence-only education
In a 20-page document submitted to the Department of Health and Human Services last week, Santelli detailed what he calls "misleading" and "scientifically inaccurate" information...
The Washington Post
WASHINGTON — Each of these assertions turns up in federally funded abstinence-only sex-education programs: Condoms fail to prevent HIV infection 31 percent of the time during heterosexual sex. The chances of getting pregnant while using a condom are 1 in 6. And condoms break or slip off nearly 15 percent of the time.
Each of them is wrong, says John Santelli, a pediatrician and professor at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health.
In a 20-page document submitted to the Department of Health and Human Services last week, Santelli detailed what he calls "misleading" and "scientifically inaccurate" information in three curricula used by programs that receive federal abstinence-only funding.
His analysis accompanied a letter from the American Civil Liberties Union demanding that HHS Secretary Mike Leavitt ensure that such programs provide medically accurate information about condoms and sexually transmitted diseases, as required by federal law.
"They have been alerted numerous times, and they haven't done anything," said Ava Barbour, an ACLU staff attorney.
"Studies have shown that the vast majority of Americans do not remain abstinent until marriage, and they need to have this vital information to protect themselves."
Two other nonprofit advocacy groups joined the ACLU: Advocates for Youth and the Sexuality Information and Education Council of the United States.
HHS spokeswoman Christina Pearson said agency officials had not reviewed the letter and other materials.
"As a general statement," she said, "I do want to note that our abstinence programs have been, and will continue to be, medically accurate, teaching young people about the healthier choices they can make in life."
The department's Administration for Children and Families (ACF) provides technical assistance to grantees and monitors the accuracy of their educational materials, Pearson said.
The government spends $176 million a year on abstinence programs.
The materials have been the subject of political and legal battles for years, with critics, including Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Calif., contending the Bush administration has ignored inaccuracies in the service of conservative ideology.
![]()
The Government Accountability Office (GAO) reported in October that the ACF did not review its grantees' materials for accuracy, but that HHS' Office of Population Affairs, which administers some abstinence programs, did. The GAO did not assess the accuracy of any materials itself.
In the ACLU filing, Santelli said that the 31 percent figure regarding condoms and HIV was from a 1993 study.
More recent studies show that the risk of an HIV-negative person being infected by an HIV-positive partner is reduced by 80 to 87 percent if condoms are used every time they have sex, Santelli wrote.
Authoritative studies also show that the chances of an unintended pregnancy while using a condom are not 1 in 6, Santelli wrote, but about 2 percent over the course of a year if condoms are used correctly every time.
And condoms break or slip off less than 4 percent of the time, not 15 percent, Santelli said.
LeAnna Benn, national director of Teen-Aid, a Spokane nonprofit which developed some of the abstinence materials, said 25 physicians had reviewed them for accuracy.
The ACLU's real goal is to persuade Congress to kill funding for abstinence programs this year, she said.
"Teen-Aid's position is always to be free from medical error and to help teens be free from consequences," she said.
"This is about the funding. ... Santelli's report, it's all regurgitated stuff. We have to ask, 'What is the motive, and why the press over something that's old news?' "
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
UPDATE - 03:21 PM
DC sniper's Muhammad's execution set for tonight
UPDATE - 03:21 PM
DOD worker assessed Fort Hood suspect months ago
UPDATE - 02:55 PM
Obama honors Fort Hood victims, condemns murders
UPDATE - 03:21 PM
White House: Obama eyeing host of Afghan choices
UPDATE - 03:21 PM
North, South Korea clash at sea before Obama visit

Ken Auletta talks about "Googled"
Ken Auletta talks about Google with Brier Dudley at the Seattle Central Library.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- 'Missing' SeaTac man found with new name, in new state
- Police: DNA from officer's slaying matches suspect
- Lt. governor's son shot by co-worker in Kent; gunman then shot self
- DNA, ballistics tie man to cop killing, police say
- McGinn next Seattle mayor; Mallahan concedes as vote gap widens
- Prosecutors consider charges against suspect in police shooting
- Three more fires ignite in Greenwood
- Trucker dies as big-rig plummets off SF bridge
- Huskies are finding talent in Tacoma
- Steve Kelley | Hasselbeck gives Seahawks' sagging season a stay of execution
- Prosecutors prepare charges against suspect in police shooting
264 - King County OKs 'don't ask' law on immigration
251 - Pelosi tours Seattle's Swedish after health-care vote
210 - McGinn more than doubles his lead over Mallahan
193 - Resolute Fort Hood soldiers ready for return
131 - Obama pressed into role as national healer
125 - Time to bring Ken Griffey Jr. back in 2010
100 - 'Missing' SeaTac man found with new name, in new state
97 - Josh Smith picks UCLA
85 - DNA, ballistics tie man to cop killing, police say
84
- For 80-year-old Maple Valley man, hoops aren't just a dream
- Plans call for Triangle to become West Seattle gateway
- 'Missing' SeaTac man found with new name, in new state
- Three more fires ignite in Greenwood
- Silver Lake restaurant destroyed by fire
- House Speaker Nancy Pelosi tours Seattle's Swedish after health-care vote
- Pakistani-American cafe, bar owner on verge of being Granite Falls mayor
- All You Can Eat | Fruit flies: thrill to the kill
- McGinn next Seattle mayor; Mallahan concedes as vote gap widens
- Rainier Pacific Financial calls rescue 'unlikely'





