Originally published Friday, May 6, 2005 at 12:00 AM
E-mail article
Print view
Share
Science, religion collide in Kansas debate
In this rural swath of northern Kansas, where the grass rolls thick and green to the horizon, a white cross dominates the landscape. Kathy Martin, a member...
CLAY CENTER, Kan. — In this rural swath of northern Kansas, where the grass rolls thick and green to the horizon, a white cross dominates the landscape.
Kathy Martin, a member of the state Board of Education, built it on her farm this spring, gathering weathered chunks of limestone from the horse pasture and laying them on a hillside.
The cross is a proud expression of Martin's faith. And as hearings challenging the role of evolution in the state's school-science curriculum began yesterday, that cross left little doubt about where she stands in the debate.
"Evolution is a great theory, but it is flawed," said Martin, 59, a retired science and elementary-school teacher who is presiding over the hearings. "There are alternatives. Children need to hear them. We can't ignore that our nation is based on Christianity, not science."
The hearings in Topeka center on two proposals. The first recommends that students continue to be taught the theory of evolution because it is key to understanding biology. The other proposes that Kansas alter the definition of science, not limiting it to theories based on natural explanations.
Whichever curriculum proposal the board adopts, members say, it would serve only as a guideline for teachers. But the standards determine what is included on statewide tests, and students would be required to learn that material.
"Part of our overall goal is to remove the bias against religion that is in our schools," said William Harris, a chemist who was the first witness to speak yesterday on behalf of changing the state's curriculum.
Dozens of national and state science organizations are boycotting the hearings, which they see as an effort to introduce creationism and intelligent design into the classroom. Intelligent design is a concept that asserts life on Earth is so complex that a higher power must have played a role in its creation.
"Public hearings and votes are not how the truth of science is determined," said Harry McDonald, president of Kansas Citizens for Science.
The debate over Kansas' curriculum, political experts say, reflects a broader effort by conservative Christian groups to move their agendas forward by electing like-minded officials at the state and local levels. GOP gains in November gave the Kansas board a 6-4 conservative majority.
"They have created a straw man," said Jack Krebs, vice president of Kansas Citizens for Science. "They are trying to make science stand for atheism, so they can fight atheism."
Take away the television cameras and the PowerPoint presentations and the scene yesterday bore a resemblance to the 1925 Scopes trial in Dayton, Tenn., where a high-school science teacher was famously convicted of violating a state law forbidding the teaching of evolution. Only this time, said Bruce Chapman, who heads Seattle's Discovery Institute, which promotes intelligent design, "This is the Scopes trial turned on its head."
![]()
Pedro Irigonegaray, a lawyer defending evolution in the debate, predicted a "whitewash" but said he would fight nonetheless.
In his testimony, Harris, the chemist, disputed the accepted wisdom that ancient simple life forms became ever more complex, evolving over billions of years into a multitude of life forms. He also said it would not be an "irresponsible deduction from the data" to say the genetic code contained in DNA was produced by an intelligent "mind."
Harris said educators who teach evolution introduce religion by rejecting the possibility that God created the universe and all living things.
Asked where he saw atheism in the Kansas science standards, Harris replied, "I see it between the lines."
E-mail article
Print view
Share
UPDATE - 12:25 AM
Fargo's fight against flooding nears its climax
Sunday's vote on health care still a cliffhanger
Apology by pope fails to calm Ireland
California tribe on spiritual quest to bring salmon home

Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
general classifieds
Garage & estate salesFurniture & home furnishings
Sporting goods
just listed
Brand New Queen Storage Bed - $700
FULL BED FRAME - $50
Jazzy Jet 3, New! - $1299
More listings
POST A FREE LISTING
shopping
events for Sunday, Mar. 21
- Vian Hunter One-day Warehouse Sale
- Gary Manuel Aveda Institute 20 Percent Discou...
- Winter Clearance Sale at Mountain to Sound Ou...
- Spring Cleaning at Helle
editors' picks
- Local jewelry designers
- Vintage, consignment and used clothing
- Maternity shopping
- Garden furnishings
- Washington men rout New Mexico, reach Sweet 16
- Husky Men's Basketball Blog | New Mexico game thread
- Missing boy's death ruled an accidental drowning
- 'Bizarre' tanker twist: Russians will bid against Boeing for Air Force contract
- Preview: Washington vs. New Mexico
- Mariners Blog | Reds 6, Mariners 2: Don Wakamatsu rips umpire over Milton Bradley "witch hunt"
- Teacher killed by wolves leaves vivid blog of Alaska wilderness
- Steve Kelley | Why can't the Huskies continue this run? | Steve Kelley
- Judge weighs Ballard 'missing link' to Burke-Gilman Trail
- State Senate passes tax package, remains at odds with House on sales tax
- New Mexico game thread
463 - Health-insurance subsidies prompt questions of affordability
195 - Russian company will bid on Air Force tanker
122 - Obama making final health care pitch to House Dems
119 - State Senate passes tax package, remains at odds with House on sales tax
119 - Sunday's vote on health care still a cliffhanger
90 - Washington men rout New Mexico, reach Sweet 16
89 - Adam Smith backs health bill; Baird still undecided
50 - So which team are you taking - UW or New Mexico?
45 - Sweeeet!
44
- 'Bizarre' tanker twist: Russians will bid against Boeing for Air Force contract
- California tribe on spiritual quest to bring salmon home
- An abundance of free Wi-Fi across the Northwest
- Lawsuit claims Boy Scouts has hidden extensive documents about sexual abuse
- Northwest Living | Island cottage sails on wings of steel and glass
- Walgreens: no new Medicaid patients as of April 16
- All You Can Eat | Won't you take me to, Nettletown -- now open on Eastlake
- Call to readers: Enter now, or forever hold your Peeps
- Is raw, unpasteurized milk safe?
- Steve Kelley | Washington coach Lorenzo Romar wins his way

