Originally published June 29, 2010 at 12:02 PM | Page modified July 1, 2010 at 1:56 PM
Comments (0)
E-mail article
Print
Share
Movie review
'The Twilight Saga: Eclipse': Better than the rest, but that's not saying much
Edward's makeup is just right, new director David Slade takes it up a notch and the young actors at its center give better performances, but "Eclipse," though best of the three so far, is still part of what has been a less-than-sparkling series.
Seattle Times movie critic
'The Twilight Saga: Eclipse,' with Kristen Stewart, Robert Pattinson, Taylor Lautner, Ashley Greene, Billy Burke, Peter Facinelli, Elizabeth Reaser, Nikki Reed, Kellan Lutz, Jackson Rathbone, Dakota Fanning. Directed by David Slade, from a screenplay by Melissa Rosenberg, based on the novel by Stephenie Meyer. 121 minutes. Rated PG-13 for intense sequences of action and violence, and some sensuality. Several theaters.
It took three movies, but the "Twilight Saga" filmmakers finally got it right. I'm speaking, of course, of vampire Edward's famously sparkling-in-the-sun skin tones, which in the previous movies bore an unfortunate resemblance to Glitter Glue. In "Eclipse," finally, he's charmingly yet subtly a-twinkle, as if somebody sprinkled him with magic sugar.
Oh, and the rest of it? Well, within the confines of the infinitely dreary "Twilight" universe, filled with morose teens and dark summer days and mysterious love triangles involving vampires and werewolves, "Eclipse" is easily the best movie of the three, but that's not saying a lot. New director David Slade ("Hard Candy") does a creditable job of balancing the swoony romance with bloodthirsty violence and swift-cut action. And the three young actors at its center give better performances than usual: Robert Pattinson's Edward seems a little less nauseated; Kristen Stewart's Bella is marginally less fidgety (though she still rarely varies her standard facial expression of slack-jawed trepidation); and Taylor Lautner, as hunky werewolf Jacob, has learned, in crucial scenes, to speak very slowly, though perhaps that's just a ploy to give us more time to admire his abs.
But watch how Anna Kendrick, in a role that takes up perhaps two minutes of screen time, conveys a liveliness and self-possession that seems to happily engulf everything around her, and you see what's missing from this franchise's moon-eyed trio: charisma. And it's all the more apparent in "Eclipse," a film (and book) in which not a great deal happens, as we're setting things up for the grand finale of "Breaking Dawn." Why do we never get an inkling of what Bella sees in Edward, or vice versa for that matter? Why do we never see them laugh together, or talk about anything other than themselves, or share an interest, or connect on a level that would explain why Bella wants to throw her life away? And likewise, Jacob is so earnestly dull (except for the aforementioned abs) that he never seems to be serious competition for Edward, despite being, by his own admission, "hotter."
"Eclipse" is padded out by various vampire/werewolf back stories, but that time might have been better spent establishing some chemistry — and some personality — between its stars. On that level, the series is simply coasting — we all know the "Twilight" world by now, goes the reasoning, and everyone knows that Bella loves Edward because, well, sun rises and snow melts and the world turns. Anyone walking into "Eclipse" without seeing the previous two movies would be genuinely perplexed; behavior that barely makes sense when you know the story becomes truly nutty without context.
Anyway, things do move along in "Eclipse," and we get a sort of "West Side Story" rumble involving vampires (both good and bad, on different teams) and werewolves (siding, reluctantly, with the good vamps), and two abnormally gorgeous villains (Bryce Dallas Howard and Xavier Samuel) with hair so impressive it deserves its own movie, and a reappearance of the Volturi, who seem to attend their very own acting school, majoring in robotics. And it's always a pleasure to see the Cullen family perpetually arranging itself into striking tableaus, as if posing for a Calvin Klein ad just before heading out to fight the bloodsuckers. There's fun to be had here, just not for Bella and Edward — and, for all but the most steadfast fans, just not enough.
Moira Macdonald: 206-464-2725 or mmacdonald@seattletimes.com
Movie review: 'The Adjustment Bureau': Hats off to a fine fantasy
Movie review: 'Beastly': Fairy-tale misfits who look like models
Movie review: 'Rango': Johnny Depp nails his role as the lizard hero in this wild Western
Movie review: 'Take Me Home Tonight': a big '80s party you may not want to crash
Actor Mickey Rooney tells Congress about abuse
![]()

Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
general classifieds
Garage & estate salesFurniture & home furnishings
Electronics
just listed
HAVANESE/LHASA MIX
Huge Baby and Kid Garage Sale
MALTESE /SHIH-TZU
More listings
POST A FREE LISTING
- Madrona dad killed by a bullet as he drove through Central Area
- Matt Flynn has good day in Seahawks' 3-way QB competition
- Brandon League looks out of his own for Mariners
- Facebook messages trigger melee at Whitman Middle School
- Why dealing for Kellen Winslow makes sense for Seahawks | Steve Kelley
- Ex-boyfriend sought in death of Renton girl, 17
- Seattle police twice face hostile crowds at scenes of violent crime
- Komen controversy hurting Race for the Cure
- Juror alternates' actions have court on red alert
- Driver fatally shot in Central Area
- Opponents of gay-marriage law say they have enough signatures
891 - Mariners look to get back on winning track against Angels
477 - Madrona dad killed by stray bullet as he drove through Central Area
458 - Typical CEO made $9.6M last year, AP study finds
166 - Seattle police twice face hostile crowds at scenes of violence crime
133 - Fact check: Ad exaggerates Obama's debt
126 - A worthwhile conversation about charter schools
104 - Brandon League blows save in the ninth...again
80 - May questions, volume seven
71 - Brandon League looks out of his own for Mariners
66
- Madrona dad killed by a bullet as he drove through Central Area
- Driver fatally shot in Central Area
- Facebook messages trigger melee at Whitman Middle School
- Downtown building fetches $55M, thanks to Amazon effect
- Opponents of gay-marriage law get unexpected aid: from Muslims
- A second chance for idle electronics
- 'Tutankhamun' in Seattle: artifacts both dazzling and humble | Art review
- Get a sitter — please — for these 10 great date-night restaurants | All You Can Eat
- Komen controversy hurting Race for the Cure
- Rescued teen tells author how story helped him survive



