Advertising

The Seattle Times Company

NWjobs | NWautos | NWhomes | NWsource | Free Classifieds | seattletimes.com

The Seattle Times

Movies


Our network sites seattletimes.com | Advanced

Originally published Thursday, October 9, 2008 at 2:50 PM

E-mail article     Print view      Share:    Digg     Newsvine

Movie Review

"What We Do Is Secret": A standout bad-boy performance in conventional punk-and-drugs biopic

Former teen heartthrob Shane West turns in a breakthrough performance as the Germs' punk-rock singer, Darby Crash, in "What We Do Is Secret," an otherwise conventional showbiz biography.

Special to The Seattle Times

PREV  of  NEXT

Shane West

 

Shane West

Movie review 2.5 stars

"What We Do Is Secret," with Shane West. Written and directed by Rodger Grossman. 92 minutes. Rated R for strong language, graphic drug use, violent fights and partial nudity. Varsity.

Like a lot of showbiz biographies, Rodger Grossman's "What We Do Is Secret" functions on two levels: as a celebration of a career, and as a vehicle for a rising young star with a talent for impersonation.

The impersonation often trumps the biography, and that's once again the case in Grossman's account of the short and splashy existence of Darby Crash, the anarchistic lead singer of the Germs, an influential late-1970s Los Angeles punk-rock band.

Grossman may have designed his movie as a tribute to the Germs, but it quickly narrows its focus to Darby, whose nihilistic impulses are traced back to an unfortunate upbringing and a habit of taking Nietzsche very seriously.

Darby is played by former teen heartthrob Shane West ("A Walk to Remember"), who smothers all romantic impulses in order to capture the negative energy of the character's provocations. Darby is a bad boy for the ages, and West makes something thrilling of his anti-social pride.

The band's other members aren't as carefully written, though they're well-played by Bijou Phillips, daughter of the late John Phillips (as the band's bassist); Rick Gonzalez (as a guitarist who later joined the Foo Fighters); and Noah Segan (as the drummer). Ashton Holmes is appropriately annoying as a manipulative male groupie.

Michele Hicks has one good scene as Penelope Spheeris, the filmmaker who chronicled punk-rock groups in her "Decline of Western Civilization" documentaries. By the time she was filming the Germs, they were so notorious that no L.A. club would book them. Spheeris had to provide her own sound stage and live audience — an episode that stands out as a missed opportunity. It's too bad she doesn't become a larger force in the film, which comes off as a rather conventional account of a young man's flirtation with fame, greed and lethal drugs.

If you've seen one movie based on the downhill slide of a rock star, do you really need to see another one? Why not just listen to their recordings instead?

It's a question that too many music biographies end up suggesting, though the temptation to resurrect the dead can be difficult to resist. While "What We Do Is Secret" may not be remembered for much more than West's performance, it's an impersonation worth saluting.

John Hartl: johnhartl@yahoo.com

Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company

NEW - 7:00 PM
Q&A: Melissa Rosenberg, 'Twilight' screenwriter

Movie review: 'Diary of a Wimpy Kid': stuck in middle school with a pretty cool cast

Eastsider Karan Brar, age 11, has key role in 'Wimpy Kid'

Movie review: 'The Bounty Hunter': About as much fun as watching Jennifer Aniston tuck her hair behind her ears

Movie review: 'October Country': Sympathy, but no hope, for dysfunctional family

Advertising

Video
Marketplace

Open Houses

Find this weekend's open house listings.
Or search by location:

nwautos

Auto Review: Grand Sport returns to Corvette line new
Already bargain priced for the handling, power and iconic status it delivers, the Chevrolet Corvette ratchets up its value-for-the-dollar appeal this ...
Post a comment
Advertising