Originally published Thursday, October 30, 2008 at 12:00 AM
Comments (4)
E-mail article
Print view
Everett judge won't hear case of lab monkey's death
An Everett District Court judge has ruled against an animal-rights advocate who sought to file a citizens complaint against three former employees of an Everett animal-testing lab who had sent a monkey through a cage washer, scalding the animal to death.
Seattle Times staff reporter
EVERETT — A judge has ruled against an animal-rights group that sought to file a rarely used citizen's complaint against three former employees of an Everett animal-testing lab who sent a monkey through a cage washer, scalding the animal to death.
Everett District Court Judge Roger Fisher said Wednesday that a jury likely couldn't reach a guilty verdict in the case if it were to go to trial. Fisher refused to overrule Snohomish County prosecutors and the city attorney's office, which didn't find sufficient evidence to file charges in the case.
Invoking a rarely used law, Pasado's Safe Haven petitioned the court to bring a citizen's criminal prosecution of three former employees at Shin Nippon Biomedical Laboratories (SNBL). The Monroe animal-rights group was concerned that no charges had been filed nearly a year after the cynomolgus macaque monkey died.
But Fisher said he had no intention of "substituting my judgment" for the decisions made by Joan Cavagnaro, the county's chief criminal deputy prosecutor, and Everett City Attorney Mike Fisher (no relation).
Bellingham attorney Adam Karp, who is representing Pasado's Safe Haven, said employees at the lab failed to remove the monkey from its cage before the animal's cage was sent through a washer with scalding hot water on Nov. 1, 2007. Lab officials have said the animal's death was an accident.
Susan Michaels, founder of Pasado's Safe Haven, said Fisher's decision "is just disappointing."
"What we would have like to have seen is a decision that would have given the opportunity for a thorough investigation," Michaels said.
Karp said he may appeal Fisher's decision to Snohomish County Superior Court, in hopes that a judge there will agree that charges should be filed.
After Wednesday's hearing, Seattle attorney John Wolfe, who represents SNBL, said the company was pleased by Fisher's decision. He said the company "feels horrible" about the animal's death.
Fisher said that he was bothered by Karp's request, especially since the attorney has a separate case pending review by the state Supreme Court dealing with the constitutionality of citizens complaints.
"Mr. Karp is asking me is to wear two hats," Fisher said, referring to his role as a judge and the fact he was asked to step in and make a decision normally left to a prosecutor.
Explaining the citizen's complaint process, Cavagnaro said "a private citizen may petition a district court to allow them to file a complaint, which initiates a formal criminal procedure."
![]()
The judge, she said, has to be satisfied that probable cause exists to allow the complaint to go forward.
Once the complaint is filed, the prosecutor "has the authority and obligation to handle any criminal proceeding in the district," she added.
Lawyers in Snohomish and King counties say the process is so rarely used that they have heard of it being presented to a judge only twice in the past 30 years.
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
UPDATE - 11:34 PM
Teen is beaten in bus tunnel; Metro to review policies
UPDATE - 12:15 AM
School levies passing in most area districts
NEW - 10:16 PM
Medical pot exceeds law, but no charges
Seattle physician Brian Krabak will do more than treat injuries at Winter Olympics
NEW - 10:39 PM
Two names dominate as Seattle begins police-chief search

nwautos
Associated Press Study: Fatal crashes down in Washington Last year Washington's roads were the scene of the fewest fatal crashes since 1955. According...
Post a comment
nwjobs
Post a comment
Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
Five reasons to stick with a job you hate -- for now
Post a comment
- Alaska Air dropping Jones Soda beverages, going back to Coca-Cola
- Man found shot dead in pickup truck in Seattle
- Seattle is first U.S. stop for Picasso exhibit
- Husky Football Blog | Pac-10 expansion to get consideration over next year
- State Senate votes to clear way for tax increases
- Idol Confessions | "American Idol" hopeful from Seattle didn't make it to Hollywood afterall
- Belltown boulevard could be completed by early next year
- Nicole Brodeur | Chrisceda Clemmons' house wasn't the only casualty
- Brier Dudley's Blog | Google rolls its own Facebook & Twitter with Gmail "Buzz"
- Sex, drug rumors swirl about N.Y. Gov. Paterson
- Republicans may be no-shows at health-plan summit
278 - State Senate votes to clear way for tax increases
250 - Pac-10 expansion to get consideration over next year
249 - Lee undergoes foot surgery
231 - Obama: GOP and Dems together can spur job growth
210 - Fort Lewis soldier charged with abusing 4-year-old, holding her head in water
193 - Rivals names Martin one of Pac-10's best recruiters
143 - Belltown boulevard could be completed by early next year
128 - Bus-tunnel attack while guards watched prompts review of Metro security
119 - White House mocks Sarah Palin from podium
92
- Seattle is first U.S. stop for Picasso exhibit
- Belltown boulevard could be completed by early next year
- 747-8 soars smoothly on first outing
- Wine Adviser | Oregon's quality pinots join the bargain ranks
- Alaska Air dropping Jones Soda beverages, going back to Coca-Cola
- Snap out of your photo funk: How to make sense of all those piles of images
- How clean are those pre-washed salad greens?
- Answers to biggest Olympic TV questions
- Brier Dudley's Blog | Google rolls its own Facebook & Twitter with Gmail "Buzz"
- Jerry Brewer | Huskies softball pitcher Danielle Lawrie: A star on the field, not in her mind






