Originally published March 20, 2008 at 12:00 AM | Page modified March 20, 2008 at 7:47 PM
Juveniles charged with violent crime have no right to a jury trial, state Supreme Court rules
A juvenile charged with a violent crime has no state constitutional right to a jury trial, the state Supreme Court ruled today. In a 6-3 ruling, the court upheld a Court of Appeals ruling in the case of Azel Chavez, who was convicted in juvenile court of
The Associated Press
OLYMPIA — A juvenile charged with a violent crime has no state constitutional right to a jury trial, the state Supreme Court ruled today.
In a 6-3 ruling, the court upheld a Court of Appeals ruling in the case of Azel Chavez. Chavez was convicted in juvenile court of several counts, including attempted first-degree murder, first-degree robbery while armed with a firearm, and second-degree assault while armed with a firearm.
In 2004, Chavez, who was 14 at the time, was accused of planning to kill three Sequim High School football coaches he was angry with. He led police on a high-speed three-county chase that ended when he collided head-on with a police car on the Hood Canal Bridge.
He was sentenced by a Clallam County judge in 2005 to up to seven years in juvenile detention, plus a 12-month firearm enhancement.
The majority rejected Chavez's assertion that juveniles who commit violent crimes are essentially treated like adult offenders, and should be allowed to have a jury trial. The high court has ruled the same in prior cases.
The court noted that even though the Washington state Constitution assures the right to a jury trial, state law has affirmed that juvenile court cases are tried without a jury.
The high court said that because of well-defined differences between Washington's juvenile justice and adult criminal systems, there is no violation of constitutional provisions.
The majority, led by Justice Charles Johnson, noted that Chavez opposed the state's motion to have him tried as an adult, where he would have had a jury trial, and that by remaining in the juvenile system, "Chavez received a substantially lesser penalty upon finding of guilt."
Joining Johnson were Chief Justice Gerry Alexander, and Justices Susan Owens, Mary E. Fairhurst, James Johnson and Justice Pro Tem. Bobbe Bridge.
The majority also upheld the Court of Appeals ruling that the state Legislature did not violate the separation of powers doctrine by permitting the court to define through common law the elements of assault.
The high court said that even with changes that have been made to the Juvenile Justice Act, there are enough differences between adult and juvenile court to continue without jury trials for juveniles.
"The claim that changes to the juvenile justice system make its focus punitive and no longer rehabilitative has been posited and consistently rejected by this court," Johnson wrote.
But the dissent, led by Justice Barbara Madsen, said even though the juvenile justice system is focused more on rehabilitation, "recognizing a right to trial by jury is not inconsistent with this defining aspect of the juvenile justice system."
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
UPDATE - 02:18 PM
Arson suspect has long history of setting fires
Band of advocates, activists now McGinn's likely insiders
Light rail to airport to begin Dec. 19
Kirkland annex 'yes' could be slipping away
UPDATE - 02:25 PM
Kent man challenges Seattle Mayor Greg Nickels' gun ban

Opening day at Crystal Mountain
Skiers crowded the slopes at Crystal Mountain for one of the resort's earliest openings.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- Homeless man, 46, arrested in Greenwood arsons
- KVI talk radio host off the air as of Thursday
- Steve Kelley | ESPN's Bill Simmons gets us: He hates Clay Bennett, too
- Police investigate videotaped arrest
- Seattle U. Men's Hoops | Big recruit goes from Huskies to Redhawks
- Mariners sign Jack Wilson to 2-year contract
- Razor found in muffin an accident, 'mortified' baker says
- Suspect's family shaken by slaying of police officer
- Mountlake Terrace woman reports razor in muffin
- Man says he will protest city's gun ban by carrying gun into community center
- Police investigate videotaped arrest
635 - OSU game thread
517 - Seattle man to pack a pistol into community center to protest mayor's ban
343 - KVI talk radio host off the air as of Thursday
143 - Mariners sign Jack Wilson to 2-year contract
142 - NYC trial for 9/11 suspects poses risks
127 - Wright State game thread
97 - Band of advocates, activists now McGinn's likely insiders
92 - Rang says Locker not ready for NFL
85 - Licata looks at boosting traffic-ticket revenue
83
- Light rail to airport to begin Dec. 19
- Homeless man, 46, arrested in Greenwood arsons
- Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
- Light rail to airport to begin Dec. 19
- Steve Kelley | ESPN's Bill Simmons gets us: He hates Clay Bennett, too
- An 802.11n upgrade could make a big difference
- KVI talk radio host off the air as of Thursday
- Washington in race for federal education funds
- Police investigate videotaped arrest
- Goodwill's Glitter Sale is Nov. 14-15





