Originally published March 13, 2008 at 12:00 AM | Page modified March 13, 2008 at 6:55 PM
WA high court says random school drug testing unconstitutional
Other states allow it. The U.S. Constitution allows it. But the Washington Supreme Court said today that random drug testing of student...
Seattle Times staff reporter
Other states allow it. The U.S. Constitution allows it. But the Washington Supreme Court said today that random drug testing of student athletes is not allowed under the state constitution.
The decision involved athletes who sued the Wahkiakum School District in 1999 after the district began requiring students to undergo urine tests if they wanted to participate in sports. If the tests indicated drug or alcohol use, the student was suspended from sports but wasn't reported to police.
At the time, officials in the Southwest Washington school district felt there was a real problem with student drug use, including use among athletes. Public surveys named youth substance abuse as the No. 1 problem there. That's not enough to allow drug testing of a student when there's no reason to suspect he or she is using drugs, the court ruled unanimously.
"The justices concluded, as we had contended, that it violates the state Constitution to require a student to give their urine without any reason to believe they've done anything wrong," said Doug Honig, a spokesman for the ACLU of Washington, which represented the students and their parents.
The ruling does not bar searches of particular student if there is a suspicion that he or she is using drugs.
A message left with the district's lawyer this morning was not returned.
The district, along with the state Attorney General's Office, argued that Washington law should follow the federal law.
While the U.S. Supreme Court has noted that the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution generally prohibits random or suspicionless searches, including drug tests, it also permits such searches if circumstances present "special needs."
In a case out of Vernonia, Ore., the court ruled that testing student athletes for drugs, even without a particular suspicion, was permitted under the U.S. Constitution because of a school's interest in students' well-being. In addition, they ruled that random testing caused fewer problems than testing based on suspicion, which would single students out. In another case, the court ruled that students who participated in other extracurricular activities could also be randomly tested.
But the Washington Constitution is different from the federal one.
Article I Section 7 reads "No person shall be disturbed in his private affairs, or his home invaded, without authority of law." That "authority of law" was lacking in the Wahkiakum searches, the state Supreme Court ruled. (It's also why drunk-driving roadblocks are not permitted in this state.)
In addition, the four-justice plurality concluded the Washington Constitution prohibits a "special needs" exception that is allows under federal law.
![]()
"A student athlete has a genuine and fundamental privacy interest in controlling his or her own bodily functions," the court ruled, "even if done in an enclosed stall, this is a significant intrusion on a student's fundamental right of privacy."
To rule otherwise, the court concluded, would open the door to random drug tests for other extracurricular activities, and even for the entire student body. While a number of other school districts have considered random drug testing over the years, only a handful have such programs in place. The ACLU's Honig said that's because such policies often draw opposition from parents and because drug testing can be expensive.
The Burlington-Edison School District in Skagit County has conducted drug and alcohol testing for more than 10 years. Students who participate in sports or extracurricular activities are tested once a year, and random checks are done on a monthly basis.
Beth VanderVeen, principal at Burlington-Edison High, said the policy has been effective. She sees it as a way to help more students say no to drugs and alcohol.
"Our intent is to try to get kids help, to try to help them make good choices," VanderVeen said.
Arlene Hulten, spokeswoman for the Lake Stevens district, said suspensions and expulsions related to drugs and alcohol have gone down since the high school began random tests of students involved in extracurricular activities. From 2005-06 to 2006-07, for example, she said the decrease was 20 percent. The district received a four-year, $587,000 grant from the U.S. Department of Education that covers the costs of testing.
The district has tested about 500 students over the past two years, Hulten said, and about 10 have tested positive for drugs or alcohol.
If the testing can't continue, then "we'll have to put our heads together and take a look at what we can do to help kids make good decisions," Hulten said. "
Seattle Times staff reporters Linda Shaw and Tom Wyrwich contributed to this report.
Maureen O'Hagan: 206-464-2562 or mohagan@seattletimes.com
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
NEW - 01:28 AM
Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
NEW - 12:13 AM
How an underdog named Mike McGinn took City Hall
Danny Westneat: Lee the Horse Logger found slow wagon shrank tumor
Parents want answers on new Seattle school boundaries
3 Cascade Mountain passes close due to snow; more rain, wind expected Sunday

Mourners gather at KeyArena for slain officer's memorial
Mourners gathered at KeyArena for the memorial service of Seattle police Officer Timothy Brenton on November 6, 2009.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- Flags were key link to cop slaying, bombings
- Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
- Briefs | Soccer: New Mexico suspends hair-pulling player Elizabeth Lambert
- McGinn pulling away as late ballots come in
- Using anti-shooter tactics, civilian Army police officer brought down gunman
- Huskies suffer another heartbreaking loss to UCLA
- Consortium on verge of owning Eastside railway land
- Suspect in officer's slaying shot by police
- Heavy snow in Cascades shuts down roads
- Stormy weather to continue today in the Seattle area
- UCLA game thread
938 - Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
389 - Weapons, bomb-making materials found in suspect's apartment
333 - Troubling portrait emerges of Fort Hood suspect
286 - Decision day for health care in the House
197 - McGinn widens lead over Mallahan in Seattle mayoral race
183 - Schools emerge as new tactic in gay marriage votes
99 - Huskies suffer another heartbreaking loss to UCLA
91 - Referendum 71 show's Washington's strategy for marriage equality is working
74 - Using anti-shooter tactics, civilian Army police officer brought down gunman
71
- Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
- Flags were key link to cop slaying, bombings
- McGinn pulling away as late ballots come in
- Consortium on verge of owning Eastside railway land
- Guest columnist | Cut the South Carolina jokes, Seattle. Get ready to compete
- Movie review | 'An Education' you won't forget
- Practical Mac | With new features, Apple's MobileMe is worth the price
- H1N1 vaccine for high-risk group coming to King Co. pharmacies
- Shoreline man killed when struck by falling tree part
- Suspect in officer's slaying shot by police





