Originally published January 31, 2008 at 12:00 AM | Page modified January 31, 2008 at 2:08 AM
Judges reject DUI breath-test results
In a ruling that could affect thousands of cases, a panel of King County judges said Wednesday that the state's toxicology lab engaged in...
Seattle Times staff reporter
In a ruling that could affect thousands of cases, a panel of King County judges said Wednesday that the state's toxicology lab engaged in "fraudulent and scientifically unacceptable" practices that have compromised breath-test readings used to prosecute suspected drunken drivers.
The ruling directly affects eight cases currently before King County District Courts and more than 100 on hold pending the ruling. But it also could affect thousands that have already been resolved, because it is expected to open the door for appeals, attorneys say.
In its blistering 29-page ruling, the panel of three District Court judges said the Washington State Toxicology Lab created a "culture of compromise" with so many "ethical lapses, systemic inaccuracy, negligence and violations of scientific principles" that the breath tests should not be used as evidence in pending DUI cases.
The judges found that a "multiplicity of errors," including how breath-test results are analyzed and verified at the lab, affected thousands of cases in recent years. Specifically, the judges heavily criticized the work of Dr. Barry Logan, the state toxicologist, and former lab manager Ann Marie Gordon.
"This is a very significant ruling," said Chief Presiding District Court Judge Barbara Linde.
However, she said the ruling does not mean the pending DUI cases necessarily will be dismissed.
Breath tests are a major piece of evidence in DUI cases but usually not the only evidence, she said. The observations of arresting officers and witnesses as well as the defendant's statements are also important in a case, Linde said.
King County Chief Criminal Deputy Prosecutor Mark Larson called the ruling "frustrating."
"We'll prosecute [suspected drunken drivers] without breath tests, which we've had to do at other times under other circumstances," he said.
Larson said the Prosecutor's Office had not decided whether to appeal the judges' ruling.
While other district-court judges in the county don't necessarily have to follow the ruling, it is expected to figure in their consideration of other drunken-driving cases.
Wednesday's ruling follows similar moves in other counties after questions were raised about the reliability of the lab's breath tests after Gordon's resignation July 20, 2007.
![]()
She had been accused of signing sworn statements saying she had personally checked that breath-test machines were working properly, when other toxicologists had in fact conducted the checks. In addition, machine-calibration errors were found to have affected other cases.
Last fall, Skagit County judges ruled in favor of allowing the tests but criticized the lab for the way it handled the testing. Snohomish County judges ruled against allowing the breath tests to be used in prosecuting drunken-driving cases.
In Wednesday's ruling, King County District Court Judges Darrell Phillipson, Mark Chow and David Steiner came down hard on the toxicology lab.
The panel said it was a "situation screaming with irony" when Logan, the state toxicologist, ordered Gordon and lab supervisor Ed Formosa to investigate an anonymous tip to the State Patrol about the false certification of the very tests they were conducting.
The judges noted that Gordon and Formosa vouched for the accuracy of the lab's chemical solutions used to verify breath tests. Logan, although knowing that Gordon had not done her own tests, didn't call for another investigation and took no steps to correct it, the judges said.
The ruling was welcomed by defense attorneys who had argued against the breath tests during an eight-day hearing before the panel of judges earlier this month.
As the hearing progressed, "it was obvious the judges took note of how many people at the toxicology lab are implicated," said defense attorney Andrea Robertson, who with Ted Vosk and Kevin Trombold argued the case on behalf of numerous clients. "Following scientific practices couldn't be more critical when someone's liberty is at stake."
The judges also criticized the software used to analyze data. Implemented in 2005 by State Patrol programmers, it was supposed to analyze the data from all 16 lab workers, but failed to include the work of four. The software, the judges wrote, was not subjected to the testing it should have undergone and as a result, significant data were eliminated.
At least 150 other errors were noted at the lab, including the signing of declarations indicating that a solution had been tested before the testing took place; listing incorrect dates for testing; and entering incorrect data. The judges said the questions over his handling of the lab "cast a long shadow over Dr. Logan's ability to serve as the State Toxicologist."
King County prosecutors last year weighed whether Gordon should face criminal charges for falsely certifying DUI tests she had not personally verified, but decided against it. Prosecutors said Gordon lacked criminal intent when she verified the samples.
Gordon signed off on the tests believing it was within her scope as supervisor to delegate some of her work to others, the prosecutor's report said. No results coming from the lab were false, the report said.
The State Patrol, which oversees the lab, has been trying to correct the problems with its breath-testing practices, spokesman Bob Calkins said Wednesday.
"The lab has another audit by the [state] Forensics Investigation Council coming up, and we look forward to getting back in front of them and letting them know what we've done," he said.
Nancy Bartley: 206-464-8522 or nbartley@seattletimes.com
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
Seattle Times Fund For The Needy offers opportunity to give
Tugboat sinks on Seattle's waterfront
Child-support error costs nearly $21,000
Danny Westneat: Bonus for supe with a B minus?
Nicole Brodeur: You have more to spare than you think you do

LA Galaxy's David Beckham
Los Angeles Galaxy's David Beckham talks about the upcoming MLS Cup final during after a team practice.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- 'The Road' takes Viggo Mortensen to Mount St. Helens and Astoria, Ore.
- Craigslist adoption ad: A plea by young mother-to-be? A scam?
- Italian lead prosecutor argues Knox motive was hatred
- Italian prosecutors request life sentence for UW student
- Tugboat sinks on Seattle's waterfront
- Child-support error costs nearly $21,000
- Man shot in chest on E. Union Street in Capitol Hill
- Washington state wines make annual best-of list
- Chase shrugs off loss of CD investors
- Mariners Blog | A Mariners-Tigers swap makes a whole lot of sense for both teams
- Senate vote clears hurdle
234 - Tight Senate vote launches health care over hurdle
119 - Child-support error costs nearly $21,000
117 - Palin excitement builds in Tri-Cities
115 - Vikings easily beat the Seahawks
108 - Prosecutor requests life in prison for Amanda Knox
87 - Cutting through breast-cancer confusion
86 - Game thread
70 - New York terror trials will restore faith in rule of law
52 - Chase shrugs off loss of CD investors
46
- Washington state wines make annual best-of list
- Nonprofits get creative using Twitter and Facebook to make donation easier
- It's possible to recover a life lost to hoarding
- Lynnwood is reinventing itself — again
- Great places to cross-country ski for free (or almost) in the Methow
- Child-support error costs nearly $21,000
- 'The Road' takes Viggo Mortensen to Mount St. Helens and Astoria, Ore.
- Recipes: Sesame Pork Roast, Sour Cream Mashed Potatoes, Gingerbread with Lemon Sauce and more
- Banff: powder, peaks & purity
- 175 foster kids in Washington get 'forever families'





