Originally published Tuesday, January 29, 2008 at 12:00 AM
E-mail ruling raises open-records issues
Under Washington's open-records laws, e-mails written on public computers are public records. But the Seattle teachers union argued successfully...
Seattle Times education reporter
Under Washington's open-records laws, e-mails written on public computers are public records.
But the Seattle teachers union argued successfully this month that e-mails about a grievance that their members sent via work computers were not public, because they weren't about Seattle Public Schools business.
"They pertain solely to union business, not anything to do with the operation of the school district itself," said Rich Wood, a spokesman for the union.
The Jan. 18 ruling by King County Superior Court Judge Julie Spector technically affects only 13 e-mail exchanges among a teacher and the Seattle Education Association's (SEA) president and executive director, but open-records advocates worry it will give public agencies an excuse not to release records that should be public.
"I think the order is just wrong," said Michele Earl-Hubbard, an attorney who specializes in open-records law. "They're using work computers; they're discussing things on public computers, presumably on public time. I can't see why they would be exempt."
Earl-Hubbard said the fact that the e-mails were written on district computers made them public. Not only that, but the district saved them — making it apparent they were the public's business, she said. But the union argued that e-mails must pass a "three-pronged" legal test: be written, be in possession of the district and have to do with district business.
Seattle Public Schools spokesman David Tucker said the district was prepared to release the e-mails but that SEA intervened. Although Seattle Public Schools was the defendant, a school-district attorney didn't argue against the union's stance in the hearing.
"We didn't have an active position on this," Tucker said.
The parent who requested the e-mails in the first place wasn't involved in the court action. In October, Jennifer Aspelund had requested access to e-mails involving a Sanislo Elementary School teacher.
People can't always afford to go to court to fight for open records, so the school district should have argued in support of its usual policy — to release e-mails written on public computers, said Micheal Reitz, general counsel for the Evergreen Freedom Foundation.
"It's just appalling that the school district would show up and indicate that it has no interest other than settling the case as quickly as possible," he said.
Rulings in a superior court don't set a legal precedent, but Earl-Hubbard said this case creates a model for what she called "cooperative lawsuits" — cases in which the parties agree.
![]()
Reitz agreed. "What was the judge going to do?" he said. "It was kind of an obvious ruling as far as settling the differences between the parties."
As for the school district, Tucker said, it won't change its policy about releasing e-mails. Wood said SEA is encouraging its members to use personal e-mail accounts for union business instead of their work accounts.
Emily Heffter: 206-464-8246 or eheffter@seattletimes.com
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
Chase won't pay for Seattle's Lake Union fireworks next year
Group hopes to build 75-megawatt solar park near Cle Elum
Stalled Bellevue tower site won't be eyesore
The end of the line, for now: Tukwila is the jewel in the crown of Link
Regional vendors vying for veterinarians' attention at convention

Gen. David Petraeus: Iraq and Afghanistan Wars
Watch highlights of General David Petraeus discussing the Iraq and Afghanistan War at the Global Leadership Series sponsored by the World Affairs Council.
Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
What not to wear to work this summer
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new car? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
nwhomes

Find a new home or condo that fits your lifestyle.
Search New Developments
Builder Directory
- Key lawmakers warn of Boeing no-strike ultimatum
- Seattle-area homebuilder losing projects to foreclosure
- Hemmed-in Ballard house to rise above
- Health-plan costs soar for individuals
- Drunken man shocks Spain with his generosity
- UW Football | Tailbacks David Freeman, Brandon Johnson ineligible
- Trees vs. houses: Narrow, leafy street is last chance for two Madrona homes waiting to be moved
- World's largest solar plant may be built in Cle Elum
- Experts work to untangle US, Korea cyber attack
- Nickels gives City Light chief $40,000 bonus
- Mass. files lawsuit against federal marriage law
913 - Health-plan costs soar for individuals
519 - Texas Rangers at Seattle Mariners: 07/09 game thread
243 - Teen charged in pit bull attacks ordered held after pleading not guilty
150 - World's largest solar plant may be built in Cle Elum
124 - Trees vs. houses: Narrow, leafy street is last chance for two Madrona homes waiting to be moved
91 - Wednesday night notes
86 - Pay parking in West Seattle?
76 - Franklin Gutierrez bails Mariners out in a 3-1 win
72 - House Dems want to expand secret briefings
63
- Seattle-area homebuilder losing projects to foreclosure
- Hemmed-in Ballard house to rise above
- Key lawmakers warn of Boeing no-strike ultimatum
- Health-plan costs soar for individuals
- World's largest solar plant may be built in Cle Elum
- Rick Steves' Europe | Beware of new and classic travel scams
- Happy Hour | Ruth's Chris has super rib-eye sliders and quality cocktails
- Trees vs. houses: Narrow, leafy street is last chance for two Madrona homes waiting to be moved
- Grab the kids and hop on Amtrak for a stress-free getaway to Portland
- All You Can Eat | "Top Chef": Seattle chefs tapped for Bravo knife fight in Vegas!





