Originally published May 11, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified May 11, 2007 at 2:02 AM
Court backs ruse to get DNA
Seattle police detectives did not violate a murder suspect's constitutional rights when they posed as lawyers and tricked him into licking...
Seattle Times staff reporter
Seattle police detectives did not violate a murder suspect's constitutional rights when they posed as lawyers and tricked him into licking an envelope to obtain a sample of his DNA, the state Supreme Court has found.
Thursday's 6-3 decision upholds the King County Superior Court conviction of John Nicholas Athan and could clear the way for police to use ruse tactics in future investigations without worrying about the impacts on criminal prosecution.
In 2004, a jury found Athan guilty of second-degree murder in the death of 13-year-old acquaintance Kristen Sumstad, whose body was found in a cardboard box behind a TV repair shop in Magnolia in 1982. Police and prosecutors said that Sumstad was raped and then strangled to keep her silent.
Athan was 14 at the time of the slaying.
Two decades later, detectives linked Athan to the cold case using a ruse that became a controversial spark in a national debate over privacy rights.
The detectives, posing as members of a fictitious law firm, sent a letter to Athan, a longtime suspect then living in New Jersey, inviting him to join a class-action lawsuit for overpaid parking tickets. After Athan licked an envelope they mailed to him and sent it back, his DNA was matched to a sample that had been recovered from Sumstad's body.
"No recognized privacy interest exists in voluntarily discarded saliva," the court wrote in its ruling, essentially saying that saliva does not fall under the legal category of protected communication between a client and his attorney.
The court did raise some concerns about the police tactics but said none was serious enough to require dismissal of the case.
"The message [from the high court] is that it is OK for police to engage in ruses to obtain evidence from people, which has long been the case," said King County Senior Deputy Prosecutor Catherine McDowall, who argued the case before the justices in January 2006. The decision also clarifies that posing as an attorney is considered to be a more sensitive, risky ruse, one police agencies likely will not want to undertake, said Senior Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Tim Bradshaw, who tried the original case.
After his 2004 conviction, Athan was given a 10-year minimum sentence, which he is now serving. His attorney challenged the conviction, saying the police action to gather the DNA evidence was illegal and violated Athan's state and federal constitutional rights.
The defense attorney, John Rolfing Muenster, said Thursday he had no comment. In a dissenting opinion, Justice Tom Chambers expressed concern over the majority opinion's potential impacts on attorney-client relations.
"Washington law prohibits a non-attorney from holding himself or herself out as an attorney," he wrote. "Permitting this unlawful and unethical conduct ... undermines the ... ability of all people to communicate freely with their attorneys without fear that the communications will be used against them."
Natalie Singer: 206-464-2704 or nsinger@seattletimes.com
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
UPDATE - 11:25 AM
Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
How an underdog named Mike McGinn took City Hall
Danny Westneat: Lee the Horse Logger found slow wagon shrank tumor
Parents want answers on new Seattle school boundaries
3 Cascade Mountain passes close due to snow; more rain, wind expected Sunday

Mourners gather at KeyArena for slain officer's memorial
Mourners gathered at KeyArena for the memorial service of Seattle police Officer Timothy Brenton on November 6, 2009.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- Flags were key link to cop slaying, bombings
- Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
- Briefs | Soccer: New Mexico suspends hair-pulling player Elizabeth Lambert
- Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
- Huskies suffer another heartbreaking loss to UCLA
- McGinn pulling away as late ballots come in
- Using anti-shooter tactics, civilian Army police officer brought down gunman
- How an underdog named Mike McGinn took City Hall
- 3 Cascade Mountain passes close due to snow; more rain, wind expected Sunday
- Heavy snow in Cascades shuts down roads
- UCLA game thread
940 - Weapons, bomb-making materials found in suspect's apartment
334 - Troubling portrait emerges of Fort Hood suspect
293 - U.S. House passes health plan
217 - Decision day for health care in the House
201 - Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
141 - Huskies suffer another heartbreaking loss to UCLA
101 - Referendum 71 show's Washington's strategy for marriage equality is working
95 - Grading the game
86 - How an underdog named Mike McGinn took City Hall
55
- Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
- Flags were key link to cop slaying, bombings
- 10 ways to take control of your health
- Danny Westneat | Lee the Horse Logger found slow wagon shrank tumor
- The birth of 'Grunge,' in photos by Michael Lavine
- 10 investing missteps to avoid
- Bombs, guns found at home of suspect in Officer Brenton's slaying
- Guest columnist | Cut the South Carolina jokes, Seattle. Get ready to compete
- How do innovators think?
- Consortium on verge of owning Eastside railway land





