Advertising

The Seattle Times Company

NWjobs | NWautos | NWhomes | NWsource | Free Classifieds | seattletimes.com

The Seattle Times

Local News


Our network sites seattletimes.com | Advanced

Originally published April 19, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified April 19, 2007 at 2:02 AM

E-mail article     Print view

Lawsuit challenges protection of salmon

Property-rights advocates, farm groups and development interests asked a federal judge Wednesday to lift Endangered Species Act (ESA) protections...

The Associated Press

EUGENE, Ore. — Property-rights advocates, farm groups and development interests asked a federal judge Wednesday to lift Endangered Species Act (ESA) protections from all threatened and endangered salmon across the West, arguing that the government failed to count fish spawned in hatcheries.

The federal government and conservation groups countered that the Endangered Species Act requires consideration of the best available science, which clearly indicates that depending on fish raised in hatcheries to boost salmon numbers will, over the long run, harm fish that spawn naturally in rivers.

U.S. District Judge Michael Hogan gave no indication when he might rule on the case, or how he might rule.

Pacific Legal Foundation, a property-rights public-interest law firm based in Sacramento, Calif., brought the lawsuit on behalf of the Building Industry Association of Washington, the Coalition for Idaho Water, farm bureaus in Idaho and Washington, the California State Grange and others.

The lawsuit builds on Hogan's 2001 ruling that NOAA Fisheries, the federal agency in charge of restoring dwindling salmon populations, violated the Endangered Species Act when it put wild and hatchery fish in the same group, known as an evolutionarily significant unit, but then protected only the wild fish. The ruling led to lifting threatened-species status for the Oregon coastal coho.

The plaintiffs want the court to lift threatened- and endangered-species listings for all 16 protected populations of salmon in Washington, Idaho, Oregon and California.

If they win, some restrictions on logging, irrigation and urban development could eventually be lifted around the West.

Several salmon populations are protected in the Seattle and Portland metropolitan areas. Irrigation water was shut off to some farms in Oregon and California in 2001 to provide water for threatened coho salmon during a drought. Many timber sales on national forests have been blocked to protect salmon.

Restrictions on hydroelectric-dam operations in the Columbia Basin would not be directly affected, because the case does not challenge 10 populations of steelhead, which overlap many of the protected salmon zones. Pacific Legal Foundation is challenging those listings, too, in a separate case in U.S. District Court in Fresno, Calif.

Pacific Legal Foundation lawyer Damien Schiff argued that NOAA Fisheries did not follow Hogan's 2001 ruling when it developed a new policy on hatchery fish and reconsidered its protections for salmon, because it made no effort to determine whether hatcheries could be relied upon as the principal means of assuring the survival of the fish.

He added that the need to consider the best available science stops once the hatchery and wild fish are put into the same population group, which NOAA Fisheries did.

Paul Lall, a U.S. Justice Department lawyer, countered that NOAA Fisheries had carefully considered Hogan's 2001 ruling and that, under the best available science, it had to consider more than just population numbers. It also had to consider whether salmon could reproduce effectively, if they were genetically diverse, and whether they were well-distributed over their geographic range.

Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company

More Local News headlines...

E-mail article Print view      Share:    Digg     Newsvine

advertising

Big demand, grim outlook for state Basic Health Plan

Flood fears dampen business, home sales

Nicole Brodeur: Homeless woman bent on giving

Chuckanut Drive to be closed up to a week

Everett Symphony may cancel rest of season after holiday shows

Advertising

Video

New Beginnings Christian Fellowship
Coming in this Sunday's Pacific Northwest Magazine: Pastor Braxton's mission is to preach a message that appeals to everyone.

PNW Magazine | Easy As Pie
Real Salt Lake wins MLS Cup
Raw Video | Real Salt Lake fans celebrate
Raw Video | Real Salt Lake receives the MLS Cup trophy
Raw Video | MLS Cup Opening Ceremony
Real Salt Lake fans enter Qwest Field
LA Galaxy's David Beckham
Real Salt Lake's Kyle Beckerman
MLS trophy arrives in Seattle

Marketplace

Open Houses

Find this weekend's open house listings.
Or search by location:

nwautos

Less is more: Group rides, good gas mileage have led to a scooter swarm in Seattlenew
Local riders say they've seen a surge in scooter interest in recent years, mostly from people wanting another commuting option. Seattle now ranks as o...
Post a comment

 
Most read
Most commented
Most e-mailed
 
 
Advertising