Advertising

The Seattle Times Company

NWjobs | NWautos | NWhomes | NWsource | Free Classifieds | seattletimes.com

The Seattle Times

Local News


Our network sites seattletimes.com | Advanced

Originally published April 3, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified April 3, 2007 at 2:01 AM

E-mail article     Print view

Forest plan's critics suppressed, judge rules

The Bush administration illegally suppressed and misrepresented the views of dissenting scientists when it eased logging restrictions under...

The Associated Press

The Bush administration illegally suppressed and misrepresented the views of dissenting scientists when it eased logging restrictions under the Northwest Forest Plan, a federal judge in Seattle has ruled.

In his ruling late Friday, U.S. District Judge Ricardo S. Martinez struck down the administration's change to the forest plan, which governs logging on 24 million acres of federal lands in Washington, Oregon and Northern California.

"Here, the dissenting views of responsible scientists were neither set forth in substance, nor their import discussed," as required by the National Environmental Policy Act, Martinez wrote.

Under the 1994 Northwest Forest Plan's Aquatic Conservation Strategy, before federal agencies could approve logging, road building or other projects, they had to determine that the projects would not harm watersheds. That wording, designed to protect salmon, had held up timber activities on 4 million acres designated for logging.

In March 2004, the Bush administration dropped the wording at the request of the timber industry.

Several U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service scientists who worked on the original Northwest Forest Plan objected, saying the change would "remove or weaken several key conservation provisions for aquatic species" and "is of great concern to us."

But such comments were not included in the environmental-impact statement prepared in conjunction with the wording change, Martinez said. Instead, some of the objections were "buried in the appendices as a summary of public comments" but were not seriously weighed by the U.S. Forest Service or Bureau of Land Management.

In one appendix, the administration misrepresented the views of the scientists who drafted the original wording by saying that they did not intend for logging projects to be evaluated for their impact on the watershed, the judge said.

Environmentalists and fishing groups who sued over the wording change were thrilled.

"The timber industry went to the Bush administration with demands to increase logging, and the Bush administration went ahead and did that," Earthjustice lawyer Patti Goldman said Monday. "The lesson is that they can't cut corners on environmental protection just because they want to cut more logs. They have to heed the science and protect the forest for all users."

Chris West, a vice president of the American Forest Research Council in Portland, which intervened in the lawsuit, said the ruling would require unnecessary, watershed-level studies rather than simply evaluating the local effect of the projects.

"We're going to be wasting the taxpayers' money on paperwork for bureaucracy's sake," he said.

Last year, U.S. Magistrate Judge Mary Alice Theiler recommended that Martinez invalidate the wording change because administration officials had failed to give a rational basis for it. Martinez agreed, but he disagreed with her finding that the environmental-impact statement "did not fail to disclose dissenting opinions."

Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company

More Local News headlines...

E-mail article Print view      Share:    Digg     Newsvine

advertising

Seattle Center, schools reach pact to tear down Memorial Stadium

Danny Westneat: Red-light tickets veer off course

County executive sworn in, lays out agenda for first 100 days

Teenage pimp convicted of human trafficking

Address of deputy accused of assault found in Monfort home, sources say

Advertising

Video

New Beginnings Christian Fellowship
Coming in this Sunday's Pacific Northwest Magazine: Pastor Braxton's mission is to preach a message that appeals to everyone.

PNW Magazine | Easy As Pie
Real Salt Lake wins MLS Cup
Raw Video | Real Salt Lake fans celebrate
Raw Video | Real Salt Lake receives the MLS Cup trophy
Raw Video | MLS Cup Opening Ceremony
Real Salt Lake fans enter Qwest Field
LA Galaxy's David Beckham
Real Salt Lake's Kyle Beckerman
MLS trophy arrives in Seattle

Marketplace

Open Houses

Find this weekend's open house listings.
Or search by location:

nwautos

Less is more: Group rides, good gas mileage have led to a scooter swarm in Seattlenew
Local riders say they've seen a surge in scooter interest in recent years, mostly from people wanting another commuting option. Seattle now ranks as o...
Post a comment

 
Most read
Most commented
Most e-mailed
 
 
Advertising