Originally published Thursday, February 8, 2007 at 12:00 AM
E-mail article
Print view
Share
Viaduct surface option eyed
House Speaker Frank Chopp — a key advocate for replacing the Alaskan Way Viaduct with an elevated highway — says he's open to...
Seattle Times staff reporter

Frank Chopp backs the elevated-highway plan but says a surface option is his second choice.
OLYMPIA — House Speaker Frank Chopp — a key advocate for replacing the Alaskan Way Viaduct with an elevated highway — says he's open to the idea of tearing down the structure and improving surface streets and transit instead.
Chopp, D-Seattle, on Wednesday said it could be a second choice if the elevated highway doesn't fly.
His statement marks an unusual moment in which the speaker and Seattle Mayor Greg Nickels appear to agree on something concerning the viaduct. The city considers the surface street and transit option its second choice.
The two sides have been battling for months. The city wants to replace the viaduct with a $3.4 billion tunnel. Chopp has argued for a $2.8 billion elevated highway. The fight has created a political impasse.
Chopp's comments came after King County Executive Ron Sims said Wednesday that he opposes both a tunnel and another elevated highway. Sims proposes improving surface streets and beefing up public transit. Details weren't available Wednesday.
Sims has met with the speaker to discuss the idea. Chopp said he told Sims: "Sounds great to me. Why don't you develop a proposal that we can go to the governor with and say, 'How can that be independently analyzed in terms of does that work or not?' "
Chopp said he was very open to Sims' idea, but he's concerned that a surface alternative couldn't carry enough traffic.
"I've got to tell you, the governor has looked at it and doesn't like it at all. Neither do a lot of other people. How do you deal with that traffic if it's backed up on I-5?" he said.
The viaduct, built in 1953, carries 110,000 cars a day and is downtown Seattle's only major north-south alternative to already overloaded Interstate 5. The viaduct needs to be replaced because the 2001 Nisqually earthquake caused major cracks in the aging structure.
Holly Armstrong, a spokeswoman for Gov. Christine Gregoire, said she doesn't expect the governor's position to change. The surface option was studied "and proven not feasible," she said.
Sims contends the surface alternative is the only politically realistic option. The past few weeks have made that clear, he said. "There's far more discussion of it than we've ever had before," he said.
Senate Transportation Chairwoman Mary Margaret Haugen, D-Camano Island, and Senate Majority Leader Lisa Brown, D-Spokane, could not be reached for comment.
![]()
Seattle Deputy Mayor Tim Ceis said that although a surface option is the city's second choice, the city is still focused on replacing the viaduct with a tunnel. Voters need a chance to weigh in March 13, he said.
That's when Seattle residents will vote on the tunnel option and the elevated-highway proposal.
Ceis said the surface alternative could cost around $2 billion. "It's not free," he said. For example, he said, any viaduct-replacement plan must include a new seawall along the waterfront.
Talk of the surface option comes as the state Department of Transportation is studying the city's tunnel proposal and a new elevated-highway configuration.
The research is being done at Gregoire's request.
To make an "apples to apples" comparison, said David Dye, a state Department of Transportation administrator, the state is looking at a four-lane elevated structure with a wide shoulder for rush-hour traffic — similar to what the city is proposing for a four-lane tunnel.
Meanwhile, members of an expert review panel appointed by Gregoire are already getting a look at the state study. Earlier this week, panelists were told they could not review the tunnel plan until after the state study is completed next week.
Staff reporter Susan Gilmore contributed to this report.
Andrew Garber: 360-236-8268 or agarber@seattletimes.com
E-mail article
Print view
Share
Federal Way officer dies at shooting scene; natural causes suspected
Police say club manager lied about shooting
Protesters in Seattle mark 7th anniversary of Iraq invasion
NEW - 10:00 PM
Jerry Large: Minding the young brain

Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
- Washington men rout New Mexico, reach Sweet 16
- Steve Kelley | Why can't the Huskies continue this run? | Steve Kelley
- Federal Way officer dies at shooting scene; natural causes suspected
- Congress clears historic health-care bill
- Husky Men's Basketball Blog | New Mexico game thread
- Larry Stone | Suddenly, Mariners spring comes with question marks
- Missing boy's death ruled an accidental drowning
- Police say club manager lied about shooting
- 'Bizarre' tanker twist: Russians will bid against Boeing for Air Force contract
- 5-year-old boy dies after falling into canal
- Dems predict historic House vote on health care
1311 - Sunday's vote on health care still a cliffhanger
157 - Free to have health care for all
130 - Is raw milk safe?
121 - Getting to know West Virginia and Missouri
79 - Huggins on UW: "Do we defend them better than they score?
61 - Brian Baird to switch to yes vote on health reform
58 - Federal Way officer dies at shootout scene
50 - Mariners 12, Angels 6: Mike Sweeney OK, Don Wakamatsu confirms Jose Lopez-Chone Figgins switch is final
46 - Mariners at Los Angeles Angels: 03/21 game thread
44
- Is raw, unpasteurized milk safe?
- 'Bizarre' tanker twist: Russians will bid against Boeing for Air Force contract
- New book dives into the underworld of giant-clam poaching
- California tribe on spiritual quest to bring salmon home
- Driving in Italy? Obey the traffic laws or risk getting a ticket after you get home
- Morocco's Essaouira lures visitors with desert walks, sea air and camel couscous
- Walgreens: no new Medicaid patients as of April 16
- Call to readers: Enter now, or forever hold your Peeps
- Intiman Theatre dusts off Depression-era 'Paradise Lost' — which speaks powerfully to us now
- Starbucks' shareholders will vote on a plan to expand the company's recycling




