Originally published Saturday, September 10, 2005 at 12:00 AM
E-mail article
Print view
Share
State to court: curb vehicle tax
The state Attorney General's Office, under new leadership, has switched sides in part of the long-running court battle over voter-approved...
Seattle Times staff reporter
The state Attorney General's Office, under new leadership, has switched sides in part of the long-running court battle over voter-approved Initiative 776.
Last year, under Democrat Christine Gregoire, the state's lawyers argued that, although the initiative repealed Sound Transit's motor-vehicle excise tax in 2002, the agency could continue to collect the tax until 2028.
A King County Superior Court judge agreed. The judge's ruling was appealed.
This week, in a brief filed with the state Supreme Court, the Attorney General's Office — now led by Republican Rob McKenna — argued the justices should in effect order Sound Transit to end the tax years earlier.
If that happens, it could save car and truck owners in King, Snohomish and Pierce counties more than $1 billion and lead to cuts in Sound Transit's bus and rail programs. The motor-vehicle tax accounts for 20 percent of Sound Transit's revenue.
The sponsor of I-776, Tim Eyman, said he was "giddy" about the state's new stance: "There's a new sheriff in town," he said of McKenna.
The new attorney general, elected last November, was a harsh critic of Sound Transit's Seattle light-rail project when he served on the agency's board from 1996 through 2001, and was frequently at odds with a majority of the board.
McKenna said in a prepared statement yesterday that he's obligated to defend state laws, including voter-approved initiatives. "Sound Transit has decided to frustrate the voters' expressed desire," he said.
Pierce County Executive John Ladenburg, who also is Sound Transit's board chairman, said he was both surprised and disappointed by the new brief. "It's a political statement, frankly, by the attorney general, and that's inappropriate," he said. "The attorney general is supposed to give unbiased legal advice, not political advice."
But Jim Pharris, senior assistant attorney general and chief author of the brief, said McKenna's history with Sound Transit played no part in shaping the state's new argument.
The office wanted to ask for an early end to the tax in Superior Court, he said, but didn't because there is no case law supporting it. State lawyers decided to include it in their argument before the Supreme Court because that court can establish new precedents, he added.
Lawyers discussed the brief with McKenna, Pharris said, and "to the extent we could make this point, he wanted us to do it."
![]()
Initiative 776 aimed to limit car-tab taxes to $30 a year by repealing not only Sound Transit's 0.3 percent excise tax but also four counties' $15 annual vehicle-license fees and statewide weight fees on light trucks. While the state Supreme Court upheld the initiative's constitutionality two years ago, its application to Sound Transit remained in legal limbo.
The reason? Sound Transit had sold $350 million in bonds in 1999, pledged the vehicle-tax revenues as collateral, and agreed to keep collecting that tax until the bonds are paid off in 2028.
To end the tax before then would unconstitutionally interfere with Sound Transit's contractual obligation to bondholders, the agency argued.
Last November King County Superior Court Judge Mary Yu agreed. It made no difference, she wrote, that the tax is expected to generate much more money — more than $2.4 billion, according to the agency's latest financial plan — than Sound Transit needs to pay off the bonds.
In the brief it filed last year with Yu, the Attorney General's Office said that, while the Legislature could pass a law to address such a "disconnect," the judiciary couldn't address it.
In their new brief to the Supreme Court, however, the state's lawyers say the justices should require Sound Transit to use the vehicle-tax money only to repay the 1999 bonds.
"Sound Transit has no legal authority to collect the tax in question, except for the limited purpose of meeting its contract obligations," they write.
In his statement, McKenna ripped Sound Transit for insisting on "spending that tax money on whatever it pleases."
Sound Transit spokesman Geoff Patrick said yesterday the agency didn't know yet how quickly the bonds could be paid off if all vehicle-tax revenue is earmarked for that purpose, or what impact it would have on programs. An analysis should be done next week, he said.
While briefs have been filed, the state Supreme Court hasn't yet decided whether to hear the I-776 appeal itself, or send it to the Court of Appeals first.
Eric Pryne: 206-464-2231 or epryne@seattletimes.com
E-mail article
Print view
Share
UPDATE - 10:48 PM
Seattle and most other school measures passing
UPDATE - 10:47 PM
King County library measure ahead by slight margin
NEW - 10:16 PM
Medical pot exceeds law, but no charges
Seattle physician Brian Krabak will do more than treat injuries at Winter Olympics
NEW - 10:39 PM
Two names dominate as Seattle begins police-chief search

Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
nwautos
Associated Press Study: Fatal crashes down in Washington Last year Washington's roads were the scene of the fewest fatal crashes since 1955. According...
Post a comment
nwjobs
Post a comment
Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
Five reasons to stick with a job you hate -- for now
Post a comment
- Steve Kelley | My treatment of Bedard has been unfair
- Is Washington's tax exemption on bullion a gold mine?
- 747-8 soars smoothly on first outing
- Alaska Air dropping Jones Soda beverages, going back to Coca-Cola
- Super Bowl ads: Betty White, Bud Light, big laughs
- Man found shot dead in pickup truck in Seattle
- Sex, drug rumors swirl about N.Y. Gov. Paterson
- Seattle is first U.S. stop for Picasso exhibit
- Lewis-McChord soldier charged with abusing 4-year-old over alphabet lesson
- Husky Football Blog | Pac-10 expansion to get consideration over next year
- Republicans may be no-shows at health-plan summit
277 - Pac-10 expansion to get consideration over next year
249 - State Senate votes to clear way for tax increases
231 - Obama: GOP and Dems together can spur job growth
209 - Lee undergoes foot surgery
203 - Fort Lewis soldier charged with abusing 4-year-old, holding her head in water
193 - Rivals names Martin one of Pac-10's best recruiters
143 - Belltown boulevard could be completed by early next year
127 - White House mocks Sarah Palin from podium
88 - Tobacco ban in Seattle parks affirms citizen right to breathe smoke-free air
83
- Seattle is first U.S. stop for Picasso exhibit
- 747-8 soars smoothly on first outing
- City, Vulcan push higher South Lake Union height limits
- Commentary: Microsoft's creative destruction
- Snap out of your photo funk: How to make sense of all those piles of images
- Wine Adviser | Oregon's quality pinots join the bargain ranks
- Belltown boulevard could be completed by early next year
- Jerry Large | Learning not to copy China
- All You Can Eat | Portage chef Vuong Loc takes Cremant space in Madrona
- Rigorous college-prep classes skyrocketing in Washington state





