Originally published August 5, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified August 5, 2007 at 2:02 AM
Drink up, but you'll be hungry later
Glasses of juice may go down more easily and more quickly than bowls of fruit, but if you drink them, beware. Your body is less likely to...
Los Angeles Times
Glasses of juice may go down more easily and more quickly than bowls of fruit, but if you drink them, beware. Your body is less likely to register the calories they contain, and you may end up overindulging.
That's the conclusion of researchers Richard Mattes and Wayne Campbell, professors of food and nutrition at Purdue University in West Lafayette, Ind., in a paper published in the International Journal of Obesity. Having a liquid form of a food instead of a solid one, they found, results in more calories consumed during the day.
The study adds to a body of research on the effects of high-calorie beverages on diet, but the new research takes the science further by comparing not just high-carbohydrate but also high-fat and high-protein drinks with solid-food equivalents.
In the three-day study, 120 men and women ate a specially prepared test lunch and later ate a dinner of their choosing. They answered questions about their feelings of hunger after the test meal and every hour thereafter until bed. They also kept a record of what they ate.
The test lunches began with a meal of chicken sandwiches accompanied by water, given as a control on the first day. On the second and third days, a liquid or a solid food sample accompanied the sandwiches. In one group, the sample was high-protein milk or cheese (a nutritionally equivalent solid). In another, it was either high-carbohydrate watermelon or watermelon juice; in a third, it was either high-fat coconut or coconut milk.
After consuming the samples, subjects ate as many of the sandwiches as they wanted, and later ate dinner until they felt full.
The results: Compared with the sandwich-and-water control, subjects who ate solid test foods consumed fewer calories after their lunches, but subjects who drank their test foods ate more. This was true whether the sample calories came from sugary, fatty or protein-rich sources.
Overall, the subjects in the solid-test-food groups gave similar answers regarding hunger and fullness as those in the li-quid-test-food groups. They also consumed about the same number of sandwiches at that meal. But key differences later emerged.
All three groups consumed the most total calories on days when a meal supplement was liquid (be it milk, watermelon juice or coconut milk), consuming 12 to 20 percent more calories than on solid-food days.
Campbell says that many prior studies have measured people's feelings of hunger but that it has been "a leap of faith to believe that feelings of hunger correspond to the amount of calories consumed."
This experiment stands out, he says, because calorie intake was directly measured — revealing that people drinking liquid foods later consumed more calories even though they had reported feeling just as full.
Dr. Zhaoping Li, an associate professor of clinical medicine at the Center for Human Nutrition, at the University of California, Los Angeles, says the study is more elegant and controlled than previous studies that compared solids and liquids, such as Coca-Cola vs. doughnuts, that were nutritionally very different.
![]()
Many signals set off by food but not beverages could lead to people feeling more satisfied, such as sight, smell, chewing and pressure of food in the stomach, says Sai Das, an assistant professor at the Friedman School of Nutrition at Tufts University.
Barry Popkin, the director of the interdisciplinary obesity program at the University of North Carolina, says the study highlights how a broad array of liquid foods do not fill people up the way solid foods do. He says the reason may be evolutionary. Today, people may get 20 to 50 percent of their calories from beverages — but for most of human history, the only beverage was water.
The idea that liquids contain nutrients, he says, is one our bodies aren't yet aware of.
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
Hundreds show up at Seattle pharmacy for shot at flu vaccine
Catholic clergy lean on House to include abortion limits in health-overhaul bill
Hundreds line up for swine flu vaccine at Sand Point pharmacy in Seattle
Senate health-care bill by year's end, Reid says
Chemical BPA in workers linked to sex problems

Opening day at Crystal Mountain
Skiers crowded the slopes at Crystal Mountain for one of the resort's earliest openings.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- Homeless man, 46, arrested in Greenwood arsons
- KVI talk radio host off the air as of Thursday
- Steve Kelley | ESPN's Bill Simmons gets us: He hates Clay Bennett, too
- Police investigate videotaped arrest
- Seattle U. Men's Hoops | Big recruit goes from Huskies to Redhawks
- Mariners sign Jack Wilson to 2-year contract
- Razor found in muffin an accident, 'mortified' baker says
- Suspect's family shaken by slaying of police officer
- Mountlake Terrace woman reports razor in muffin
- Man says he will protest city's gun ban by carrying gun into community center
- OSU game thread
672 - Police investigate videotaped arrest
635 - Seattle man to pack a pistol into community center to protest mayor's ban
357 - GOP clueless as families struggle with health care
197 - NYC trial for 9/11 suspects poses risks
132 - Band of advocates, activists now McGinn's likely insiders
101 - Kent man challenges Seattle Mayor Greg Nickels' gun ban
99 - Wright State game thread
97 - Licata looks at boosting traffic-ticket revenue
89 - Light rail to airport to begin Dec. 19
71
- Light rail to airport to begin Dec. 19
- Homeless man, 46, arrested in Greenwood arsons
- Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
- Light rail to airport to begin Dec. 19
- Steve Kelley | ESPN's Bill Simmons gets us: He hates Clay Bennett, too
- An 802.11n upgrade could make a big difference
- KVI talk radio host off the air as of Thursday
- Washington in race for federal education funds
- Police investigate videotaped arrest
- Goodwill's Glitter Sale is Nov. 14-15








