FCC warns Comcast: Keep the Internet open

The Federal Communications Commission's finding that Comcast violated federal policy by blocking a file-sharing program is a positive development toward ensuring an open Internet.

The order, a 3-2 vote with Republican Chairman Kevin Martin joined by the commission's two Democrats, Jonathan Adelstein and Michael Copps, is significant but should have been more severe. The FCC chose not to fine Comcast, making the punishment a warning. The ruling does force Comcast to not block or degrade the sharing of large data files.

Expect Comcast to challenge the FCC in court. The cable giant contends the FCC's decision is based on a set of unenforceable principles, not hard and fast rules.

The possibility of a legal battle should not deter Congress from implementing a network-neutrality law. Comcast's actions and continued assertion that blocking content is nothing more than network management bolsters the need for regulation of the Internet. Such a law would ensure the Internet remains an open platform and a conduit to commerce and creativity.