Originally published June 27, 2008 at 12:00 AM | Page modified June 27, 2008 at 3:47 AM
Editorial
That activist court spills oil on logic
The U.S. Supreme Court apparently could not find a law, ruling or precedent to guide its decision over punitive damages for the Exxon Valdez oil spill, so it made one up.
The U.S. Supreme Court apparently could not find a law, ruling or precedent to guide its decision over punitive damages for the Exxon Valdez oil spill, so it made one up.
The result was a slap in the face for many residents of Alaska, who had their economy, way of life and pristine environment drowned in 11 million gallons of oil in 1989 when the Exxon Valdez supertanker ran aground on Bligh Reef.
Clearly uncomfortable with the idea of punitive damages, the court hems and haws through legal history ruminating about the role of damages and their application. In circumstances where the court might otherwise have opted to defer to a jury's award, or the judgment of lower courts, or even wait for lawmakers to act, the justices acted to slash the penalty.
Exxon had already paid out large sums of money in criminal fines, for cleanup, settlement of a civil action and voluntary payments to private parties. In 1994, a jury concluded additional punitive damages were appropriate and set the amount at $5 billion. An appeals court cut that in half, and the high court whacked that down to $500 million.
The rationale gets awfully thick. Maritime law gets squishy about making a corporation pay punitive damages for the acts of a managerial surrogate. Unless the chairman of the board is at the helm, it would not stick — or something.
The justices mumbled about not being too impressed by punitive damages as retribution or to deter future bad behavior. They were stuck on an older concept of "enormity."
Hmm, enormity. A 987-foot oil tanker runs aground after its captain turns the helm over to an unlicensed subordinate and leaves the bridge. Eleven hours later, the captain's blood-alcohol content is .241.
Thirteen-hundred miles of Alaskan shoreline are fouled, an estimated 30,000 birds are killed, and the rest is brutal history.
The court leaves the public and politicians to draw their own conclusions about how grievous behavior by oil companies would be enforced in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge or in expanded offshore drilling.
This is a potentially expensive victory for Exxon, which made a $40 billion profit last year.
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
Leonard Pitts Jr. / Syndicated columnist: A tragic clash of cultures

Mourners gather at KeyArena for slain officer's memorial
Mourners gathered at KeyArena for the memorial service of Seattle police Officer Timothy Brenton on November 6, 2009.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- Flags were key link to cop slaying, bombings
- Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
- Briefs | Soccer: New Mexico suspends hair-pulling player Elizabeth Lambert
- McGinn pulling away as late ballots come in
- Using anti-shooter tactics, civilian Army police officer brought down gunman
- Huskies suffer another heartbreaking loss to UCLA
- Consortium on verge of owning Eastside railway land
- Suspect in officer's slaying shot by police
- Heavy snow in Cascades shuts down roads
- Stormy weather to continue today in the Seattle area
- UCLA game thread
938 - Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
389 - Weapons, bomb-making materials found in suspect's apartment
333 - Decision day for health care in the House
197 - McGinn widens lead over Mallahan in Seattle mayoral race
183 - Schools emerge as new tactic in gay marriage votes
99 - Huskies suffer another heartbreaking loss to UCLA
91 - Referendum 71 show's Washington's strategy for marriage equality is working
76 - Using anti-shooter tactics, civilian Army police officer brought down gunman
71 - U.S. House passes health plan
63
- Suspect shot as city mourns slain officer
- Flags were key link to cop slaying, bombings
- McGinn pulling away as late ballots come in
- Consortium on verge of owning Eastside railway land
- Guest columnist | Cut the South Carolina jokes, Seattle. Get ready to compete
- Movie review | 'An Education' you won't forget
- Practical Mac | With new features, Apple's MobileMe is worth the price
- H1N1 vaccine for high-risk group coming to King Co. pharmacies
- Shoreline man killed when struck by falling tree part
- Suspect in officer's slaying shot by police





