Originally published Friday, December 28, 2007 at 12:00 AM
Editorial
Lawyers get it, too
There are ratings and rankings of doctors, real-estate agents, car dealers, builders of buildings, business executives and other professions...
There are ratings and rankings of doctors, real-estate agents, car dealers, builders of buildings, business executives and other professions.
But wouldn't you know that a Web site rating lawyers would trigger a lawsuit against the alleged injustice of it all? How silly. The lawyers' ratings are just as much opinion as many of the other listings.
That didn't stop Seattle lawyers John Henry Browne and Alan Wenokur from suing Avvo.com, which promises "free ratings for every lawyer so you can choose the right lawyer." The two attorneys said Avvo.com was engaging in unfair and deceptive practices by falsely claiming to be objective, reliable and factual.
Fortunately for consumers and other supporters of free speech, U.S. District Judge Robert Lasnik dismissed the case. He ruled the site's rankings were clear examples of opinion — free speech protected by the First Amendment.
Lasnik said Avvo.com doesn't pretend its information is something beyond subjective and advisory and does not violate the Washington Consumer Protection Act.
Lasnik's ruling makes a ton of sense. Are lawyers a dramatically different breed than doctors or business owners or electricians? The public has a free-speech right to the information provided by magazines, newspapers and on a variety of Web sites.
Avvo.com CEO Mark Britton said the ruling means the site will continue to expand research and ratings but has turned off numerical ratings for most lawyers, opting instead to provide a more generalized rating.
Just because lawyers' feelings are hurt by a less than favorable rating doesn't mean free speech and the sharing of information should be diminished. A cherished constitutional right has to be protected.
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
NEW - 12:45 AM
Leonard Pitts Jr. / Syndicated columnist: The peril of lower standards in the 'new journalism'
George Will / Syndicated columnist: Huckabee's detour from reason in Obama theory
Lance Dickie / Seattle Times editorial columnist: Empower health care reform close to home
Rewind | Seattle Times Editorial Board interviews school officials
Leonard Pitts Jr. / Syndicated columnist: When punishment is a crime

nwautos
Turismo upgrade "Gran Turismo 5: XL Edition" for PlayStation 3 has features such as new car-tuning settings, new NASCAR vehicles, better replay video...
Post a comment
- Council members get briefing on arena proposal, minus details
- Lakewood cop accused of embezzling $150K meant for slain officers' families
- Social worker recounts minutes before Powell fire
- 3 big health insurers stockpile $2.4 billion as rates keep rising
- Washington men walloped by Oregon, 82-57
- Agency set to investigate handling of 911 call about Josh Powell
- Quick decisions: How Washington hired its new football staff
- Historic day for gay marriage as another fight looms
- Justin Wilcox's versatile defensive style is the right fit for Huskies | Jerry Brewer
- Wanted in Seattle classrooms: more teachers of color
- Gay-marriage bill passes House, awaits Gregoire's signature
510 - AP Source: Obama to change birth control rule
421 - Wanted in Seattle classrooms: more teachers of color
419 - Council members get briefing on arena proposal, minus details
390 - Rough road again
109 - A few late-night notes
98 - USA Today further spells out how Mariners, handful of clubs next in line for huge cash windfall
76 - Marijuana legalization initiative set to go on Nov. ballot
76 - UW throttled at Oregon
68 - New TV deals won't guarantee everlasting success; that part will still take work by Mariners and others
62
- Wanted in Seattle classrooms: more teachers of color
- State Medicaid program to stop paying for unneeded ER visits
- 3 big health insurers stockpile $2.4 billion as rates keep rising
- Economy, blogs give survivalists new reason to look to Northwest
- Bellevue College adds a third bachelor's degree program
- State's share of mortgage settlement: $648 million
- Darren Berg gets 18-year sentence for Ponzi scheme
- One man's audacious pursuit of sailing history
- $25B settlement reached over foreclosure abuses
- 'Gauguin and Polynesia': dazzling mix-and-match | Art review







