Originally published Tuesday, May 10, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Editorial
On balance, state must support trade
It is unfortunate that three Washington Congressmen — Democrats Brian Baird, Rick Larsen and Adam Smith — oppose a trade agreement...
It is unfortunate that three Washington Congressmen — Democrats Brian Baird, Rick Larsen and Adam Smith — oppose a trade agreement with Central America.
The Republican administration has treated them dismissively, offering them nothing for their votes. But hundreds of thousands of jobs in this state depend on trade. The question of whether this state is for trade agreements ought to be settled: We are for them.
Despite serious questions about worldwide environmental impacts and the pace of globalization, on balance, it is in the interest of the people of this state to see the trade of nations expand.
The Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA) is not so important in itself. It gives Microsoft greater protection for software copyrights, and Eastern Washington French-fry exporters a better shot at a market now served by Canada. But the market is fairly small. The CAFTA economies — Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica and the Dominican Republic — are about one-seventh the size of Mexico's.
The main importance of CAFTA is as a marker, a fight over trade in general. It's another round in the match that began with NAFTA — and probably the easiest way to judge it is to consider how NAFTA worked out.
The North American Free Trade Agreement, which this page supported, was supposed to increase trade and trade-related jobs in the United States, help develop Mexico and encourage democracy there. Opponents predicted a "giant sucking sound" of jobs leaving the United States and a "race to the bottom" for workers in Mexico.
Most of these predictions were exaggerated. NAFTA did destroy some U.S. jobs, but the state's count of jobs vacuumed up is 4,887. During that decade, half a million net new jobs were created in Washington.
NAFTA had a bigger effect on Mexico. It hurt subsistence farmers in the south — which is why white corn is excluded from CAFTA — and helped Mexican exporters of everything from guacamole to car engines. Mexico was already the No. 4 trading partner of the United States. It rose to No. 2, eclipsing even China. (Canada is No. 1.)
NAFTA sped up Mexico's industrialization — with some bad environmental impacts, like pressure on aquifers, but on balance to the benefit of the health, wealth and civic life of Mexicans. One example: Life expectancy in Mexico has risen from 70 in 1990 to 73.6 today.
CAFTA still comes with questions. Does it have too much protection of investors or patent owners? Why does it let in virtually no sugar to undermine the monopoly price charged here?
CAFTA will have to be adjusted from time to time, but it is part of a process that is good, and our delegation should support it.
NEW - 12:45 AM
Leonard Pitts Jr. / Syndicated columnist: The peril of lower standards in the 'new journalism'
George Will / Syndicated columnist: Huckabee's detour from reason in Obama theory
Lance Dickie / Seattle Times editorial columnist: Empower health care reform close to home
Rewind | Seattle Times Editorial Board interviews school officials
Leonard Pitts Jr. / Syndicated columnist: When punishment is a crime

Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
nwautos
(Daihatsu) Daihatsu FC Sho Case This futuristic four-seater debuted at the Tokyo auto show in December. Its seats can fold flat into the floor and th...
Post a comment
- Madrona dad killed by a bullet as he drove through Central Area
- Matt Flynn has good day in Seahawks' 3-way QB competition
- Brandon League looks out of his own for Mariners
- Facebook messages trigger melee at Whitman Middle School
- Why dealing for Kellen Winslow makes sense for Seahawks | Steve Kelley
- Ex-boyfriend sought in death of Renton girl, 17
- Komen controversy hurting Race for the Cure
- Seattle police twice face hostile crowds at scenes of violent crime
- Juror alternates' actions have court on red alert
- Driver fatally shot in Central Area
- Opponents of gay-marriage law say they have enough signatures
890 - Mariners look to get back on winning track against Angels
477 - Madrona dad killed by stray bullet as he drove through Central Area
420 - Typical CEO made $9.6M last year, AP study finds
165 - Fact check: Ad exaggerates Obama's debt
126 - Seattle police twice face hostile crowds at scenes of violence crime
124 - A worthwhile conversation about charter schools
92 - Brandon League blows save in the ninth...again
72 - May questions, volume seven
67 - Brandon League looks out of his own for Mariners
63
- Madrona dad killed by a bullet as he drove through Central Area
- Driver fatally shot in Central Area
- Facebook messages trigger melee at Whitman Middle School
- Downtown building fetches $55M, thanks to Amazon effect
- Opponents of gay-marriage law get unexpected aid: from Muslims
- A second chance for idle electronics
- Get a sitter — please — for these 10 great date-night restaurants | All You Can Eat
- Komen controversy hurting Race for the Cure
- Rescued teen tells author how story helped him survive
- Sounders FC salaries released for 2012 season | Sounders FC Blog







