Originally published Sunday, September 14, 2008 at 12:00 AM
Comments (0)
E-mail article
Print view
Danny Westneat
Where has McCain's honor gone?
It was 1997 when I had my John McCain moment. That's when as a member of the press you swoon a bit as you realize this guy is different from the rest.
![]() |
Seattle Times staff columnist
It was 1997 when I had my John McCain moment.
That's when as a member of the press you swoon a bit as you realize this guy is different from the rest.
I was a reporter covering Congress. The leaders of 230 Indian tribes had gathered across the street from the Capitol, an emergency meeting to protest two policies that our senator at the time, Slade Gorton, had tried to slip through without a public hearing.
The laws would have eroded the tribes' rights to self-governance, as spelled out in 150-year-old treaties. That sounds technical. But in Indian country, those treaties — which they were forced to sign — have long been considered the only tiny hold on power they have.
Now someone was trying to roll them back. As some tribes were finally emerging from decades of poverty and isolation.
I ran into McCain heading to the meeting. He had no aides with him. He was off to "go stand with the tribes," he said.
Go back and read the treaties, McCain said. It's obvious what we agreed to. We took millions of acres of their land and, in turn, signed these deals. To unilaterally rewrite the terms now is another act of deception, betrayal, bad faith.
Our honor is at stake, he said. Not theirs. Ours.
I've been a McCain fan ever since. The tribes had no clout then, and there were no TV cameras around. Here was a politician doing something not for his own benefit, but because it was right.
Which makes the detestable campaign he's now running difficult for me to come to grips with.
A number of readers have chided me for it. How can I keep calling McCain honorable?
I can't anymore. Not after last week.
![]()
All candidates spin. And campaigns can get rough. But McCain has crossed into outright lies.
Such as the ad he cut saying Barack Obama wants to have comprehensive sex-ed classes for kindergartners.
"Learning about sex before learning to read? Barack Obama. Wrong on education. Wrong for your family," the ad says, mixing photos of schools and kids with a menacing or confused Obama.
You can see the many ways this ad is not true at factcheck.org, a nonpartisan center at the University of Pennsylvania that seeks to combat "deception in U.S. politics." It called the ad "simply false."
It's also simply ugly. It's one thing to misstate your opponent's plans (Obama has done that). It's quite another to say — to lie — that he's unhinged, alien, a danger to children.
It's not only this one ad. Here are other phrases factcheck.orghas used to describe other McCain ads, all put out this past week: "Less than honest." "Doubly false." "Particularly egregious."
Does lying matter anymore? Is it so common that voters will shrug and say: "Oh well, everybody does it. What's the big deal?"
This is the presidency. And this time it isn't lies from an independent group or anonymous blog. It's from the candidate himself.
What happened to McCain? Maybe he has many sides. Or maybe I judged him wrong. But I remember the reason he impressed me was because he showed me, in person, how he believed in something intangible, a principle beyond the game of politics.
Now I can't tell what he believes in. Beyond winning. Any sleazy way he can.
Danny Westneat's column appears Wednesday and Sunday. Reach him at 206-464-2086 or dwestneat@seattletimes.com.
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
More Danny Westneat headlines...
E-mail article
Print view Share:
Digg
Newsvine
dwestneat@seattletimes.com | 206-464-2086
Danny Westneat: TV's digital promised land
Danny Westneat: When rules trump ingenuity
Danny Westneat: What hooked you on the Web
Danny Westneat: Taking the bad with the good
Danny Westneat: Showing up is a show of strength

Snoqualmie flooding
Early flooding in the Snoqualmie Valley from the Snoqualmie and Tolt Rivers.
AP's News Minute
All of today's news in one minute.
nwhomes

Find a new home or condo that fits your lifestyle.
Search New Developments
Builder Directory
- Mystery solved: Gov. Gregoire visiting troops in Iraq
- Kirkland's Jason Mesnick spills about "The Bachelor"
- Puyallup mom who attacked child molester with baseball bat pleads guilty to assault
- Pelicans fall out of sky from Mexico to Ore.
- Steve Kelley | UW football is "a sleeping giant" and Nick Holt plans to inject adrenaline
- In court, nightclub shooting suspect regained right to gun
- Tax cuts a big part of Obama's $775B plan
- 11 gay bars get letters threatening ricin attacks
- Chew on this: We'll soon be able to grow replacement teeth
- Federal racketeering trial begins for Washington Hells Angels
- Israeli forces bisect Gaza, surround biggest city
510 - Holt's contract released --- he's making a lot
281 - 11 gay bars get letters threatening ricin attacks
148 - 2009 starts...slowly
89 - A few more Holt notes
68 - UW football is "a sleeping giant" and Nick Holt plans to inject adrenaline
52 - Budget deficit looms largest
45 - Donatell to USC? More Wednesday morning links
45 - Tuesday night wrapup
44 - Pelicans fall out of sky from Mexico to Ore.
43
- 11 gay bars get letters threatening ricin attacks
- Chew on this: We'll soon be able to grow replacement teeth
- Happy Hour | A taste of Hawaii on Queen Anne at Genki Sushi
- Homemade version of Buffalo Chicken Wings saves on calories, not on taste
- Pelicans fall out of sky from Mexico to Ore.
- Eating certain foods together helps with nutrient absorption
- Mystery solved: Gov. Gregoire visiting troops in Iraq
- Change your life in 2009 with these 52 tips
- Washington state employee hiring freeze lifted
- Steve Kelley | UW football is "a sleeping giant" and Nick Holt plans to inject adrenaline










