Originally published July 26, 2007 at 12:00 AM | Page modified July 26, 2007 at 2:02 AM
Judge says PC-system allegations not libel
Sir Harold Evans wrote about whether computing pioneer Tim Paterson copied colleague Gary Kildall's PC operating system...
Seattle Times technology reporter

Tim Paterson denied copying Gary Kildall's system.

Sir Harold Evans wrote about PC-era controversy.

Gary Kildall developed the operating system CP/M.
A ruling Wednesday in a libel lawsuit rekindled memories of a long-lingering dispute about the true "paternity" of the personal computer operating system that later became the basis for Microsoft Windows.
At issue were statements in Sir Harold Evans' 2004 book "They Made America: From the Steam Engine to the Search Engine: Two Centuries of Innovators." One chapter was devoted to Seattle native Gary Kildall, described as "the true founder of the personal computer revolution and the father of PC software."
Evans, a prolific author and veteran newspaper editor, delved into a controversy dating back to the early days of the PC era: Whether Tim Paterson, another Seattle computing pioneer, copied Kildall's early PC operating system known as CP/M — the standard for the 8-bit Intel 8080 chip in the late 1970s — in designing his own operating system, which was later purchased by Microsoft and became MS-DOS.
In the lawsuit he filed, Paterson denied — as he has done repeatedly — having access to the source code for CP/M while he was building what was called QDOS, for Quick and Dirty Operating System, at Seattle Computer Products in 1980. He acknowledges that his operating system, refined and sold to Microsoft, was designed to be similar to CP/M so programs for the 8080 could run on the next-generation 8086 machines.
But the court Wednesday turned back Paterson's suit, finding that Evans' reporting on the events did not meet the definition of libel.
"The Court finds that Evans' statements that Paterson 'ripped-off' CP/M, or '[took] a ride on' CP/M, are mere opinion based on the facts disclosed in the Kildall chapter," U.S. District Judge Thomas Zilly wrote in his ruling. Zilly found that other statements — a total of seven specific passages were disputed — were "not provably false."
"Evans fully discloses the basis for his statements in the Kildall chapter, and Paterson's dislike for Evans' conclusions does not make them defamatory," Zilly wrote.
Evans' book included both Kildall's and Paterson's views on the issue, though he did not interview either man, relying instead on an extensive written record. Kildall died in 1994.
Furthermore, the judge found no evidence that Evans acted with actual malice, a requirement for a statement about a semi-public figure to be libelous.
The case, filed in U.S. District Court in Seattle in October 2005, was dismissed.
"The author in this case championed Kildall's version of events that we found to be libelous," said Paterson's attorney, Michael Tomkins.
Tomkins said he had not yet discussed with his client whether to appeal the ruling.
![]()
The historical significance of Evans' work was not lost on Paterson, who decided to bring a libel case against the author after so much had already been written about the issue.
"Where the other [previous] publications were sort of novels that spoke to what other people's perception was, this particular publication was in fact a textbook and Kildall's autobiography was for the first time brought to the attention of the public with very specific concepts, words and allegations that needed finally to be answered and put to bed," Tomkins said.
Evans was represented by the Seattle law firm of Davis Wright Tremaine, which also represents The Seattle Times.
Benjamin J. Romano: 206-464-2149 or bromano@seattletimes.com
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
Chase shrugs off loss of CD investors
Sunday Buzz: Expedia, Intelius, Classmates slapped by Senate report
Denny Triangle gains skyline, but tenants slow to come
UPDATE - 08:56 PM
Senate Democrats at odds over health care bill
Your Funds: Money for nothing: Some investors pay for advice they never get

LA Galaxy's David Beckham
Los Angeles Galaxy's David Beckham talks about the upcoming MLS Cup final during after a team practice.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- 'The Road' takes Viggo Mortensen to Mount St. Helens and Astoria, Ore.
- Craigslist adoption ad: A plea by young mother-to-be? A scam?
- Italian lead prosecutor argues Knox motive was hatred
- Tugboat sinks on Seattle's waterfront
- Child-support error costs nearly $21,000
- Italian prosecutors request life sentence for UW student
- Man shot in chest on E. Union Street in Capitol Hill
- Washington state wines make annual best-of list
- Chase shrugs off loss of CD investors
- Mariners Blog | A Mariners-Tigers swap makes a whole lot of sense for both teams
- Senate vote clears hurdle
239 - Child-support error costs nearly $21,000
120 - Vikings easily beat the Seahawks
119 - Tight Senate vote launches health care over hurdle
119 - Palin excitement builds in Tri-Cities
117 - Cutting through breast-cancer confusion
89 - Prosecutor requests life in prison for Amanda Knox
88 - Game thread
70 - New York terror trials will restore faith in rule of law
53 - Chase shrugs off loss of CD investors
48
- Washington state wines make annual best-of list
- Nonprofits get creative using Twitter and Facebook to make donation easier
- It's possible to recover a life lost to hoarding
- Lynnwood is reinventing itself — again
- Great places to cross-country ski for free (or almost) in the Methow
- 'The Road' takes Viggo Mortensen to Mount St. Helens and Astoria, Ore.
- Child-support error costs nearly $21,000
- Recipes: Sesame Pork Roast, Sour Cream Mashed Potatoes, Gingerbread with Lemon Sauce and more
- Banff: powder, peaks & purity
- 175 foster kids in Washington get 'forever families'







