Originally published Friday, May 30, 2008 at 12:00 AM
Book review
Arts and politics collide in Russia in "The Magical Chorus"
In "The Magical Chorus," Solomon Volkov presents an encyclopedic overview of the past 100 years of Russian artistic life.
Special to The Seattle Times
"The Magical Chorus: A History of Russian Culture from Tolstoy to Solzhenitsyn"
By Solomon Volkov, translated by Antonina Bouis
Knopf, 333 pp., $30
In "The Magical Chorus," Solomon Volkov presents an encyclopedic overview of the past 100 years of Russian artistic life, filled with stories about the works, personal dramas and political struggles of the country's best-known writers, composers and performers. At its best it is an entertaining, gossipy book. At its worst it is a rambling series of disjointed vignettes and undigested details that highlight the book's lack of rigor and larger conceptualization.
The animating idea behind Volkov's book, such as there is, is the notion that culture and politics are "indivisible" and that this fact has never before been so starkly evident as in Russia in the 20th century, when "perhaps for the first time in history did such a brutal experiment of politics being forced into the cultural life of such a huge country take place over such a long period."
As far as it goes, this pronouncement is beyond argument, and "The Magical Chorus" recounts the many famous clashes between Russia's rulers and her artists. We read about the battles between Leo Tolstoy and Tsar Nicholas II, between Dmitry Shostakovich and Stalin, between Alexander Solzhenitsyn and Brezhnev.
These accounts reinforce the traditional view of the relationship between power and culture in Russia as essentially antagonistic. Yet although the frequently tortuous repression of artistic expression was real and profound, the history of this relationship was more complex than Volkov depicts here.
A musicologist and noted (as well as controversial) author, Volkov was born and raised in the former Soviet Union, immigrating to the United States in the 1970s. His personal story shapes "The Magical Chorus" in important ways. Volkov has known many of the people he writes about (a fact he never fails to mention), and the finest parts of the book draw on his own experiences of life in the USSR. His intimate knowledge of the Khrushchev and Brezhnev eras lends his discussion a subtle and nuanced richness.
Consequently, these parts have the unintended effect of making the weaknesses of the book's first half that much clearer. When writing about periods he did not experience, Volkov resorts to stale clichés and ill-informed assertions. What's more, despite Volkov's stated goal of placing his study of culture within the proper social and political context, the parade of writers, poets, artists and movements hangs awkwardly in the air, cut off from the world that gave birth to them and which is vital to their comprehension.
A product of the age of cynicism and dissidents, Volkov fails to recognize the enormous power the utopian Communist ideology of the early 20th century exercised over so many Russian intellectuals. Not only did they merely go along with the radical designs of the Bolsheviks, as he suggests, rather they shared the revolutionaries' belief in mankind's ability to leap headlong into a radiant future, thus helping to make the horrors of the Soviet experience possible.
It is a blindness of this sort to the complicated, shifting interplay between culture and politics, together with a pinched definition of the former centered on the creations of the great masters, that leads Volkov to conceive of culture's role in society in simplistic terms. He reduces this messy interaction to a tidy, unconvincing morality play between the forces of darkness and light. This chorus sings off-key.
Douglas Smith is a resident scholar at the University of Washington and the author of "The Pearl: A True Tale of Forbidden Love in Catherine the Great's Russia" (Yale University Press).
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
Kids books: A conversation with 'Strega Nona' author Tomie dePaola
Book review: 'The Lacuna' is an ambitious bridge of cultures, ideologies, decades
Authors Greg Bear and Lester R. Brown in Seattle
Sarah Palin goes public with new memoir, "Going Rogue"
Local books: Illustrated Goethe, the Battle of Seattle and Wheedle on the Needle

Opening day at Crystal Mountain
Skiers crowded the slopes at Crystal Mountain for one of the resort's earliest openings.
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
How to tell your office you're gravely ill
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new sedan? Weigh the impact of your choice on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
- Homeless man, 46, arrested in Greenwood arsons
- KVI talk radio host off the air as of Thursday
- Steve Kelley | ESPN's Bill Simmons gets us: He hates Clay Bennett, too
- Police investigate videotaped arrest
- Seattle U. Men's Hoops | Big recruit goes from Huskies to Redhawks
- Mariners sign Jack Wilson to 2-year contract
- Razor found in muffin an accident, 'mortified' baker says
- Suspect's family shaken by slaying of police officer
- Mountlake Terrace woman reports razor in muffin
- Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
- Police investigate videotaped arrest
631 - Seattle man to pack a pistol into community center to protest mayor's ban
235 - Light rail to airport to begin Dec. 19
177 - GOP clueless as families struggle with health care
173 - KVI talk radio host off the air as of Thursday
139 - Mariners sign Jack Wilson to 2-year contract
129 - Wright State game thread
97 - Person of interest in custody in connection with Greenwood arsons
96 - Rang says Locker not ready for NFL
85 - Licata looks at boosting traffic-ticket revenue
72
- Light rail to airport to begin Dec. 19
- Homeless man, 46, arrested in Greenwood arsons
- Ivar's undersea billboards a hoax devised as marketing ploy
- Steve Kelley | ESPN's Bill Simmons gets us: He hates Clay Bennett, too
- KVI talk radio host off the air as of Thursday
- Washington in race for federal education funds
- Light rail to airport to begin Dec. 19
- An 802.11n upgrade could make a big difference
- Police investigate videotaped arrest
- Goodwill's Glitter Sale is Nov. 14-15





