Originally published Friday, January 12, 2007 at 12:00 AM
Book Review
"The Little Book of Plagiarism" | An original take on modern plagiarism
It would have been nice to have this little book around last year. With novelist Kaavya Viswanathan disgraced...
Special to The Seattle Times
"The Little Book of Plagiarism"
by Richard A. Posner
Pantheon, 116 pp., $10.95
It would have been nice to have this little book around last year.
With novelist Kaavya Viswanathan disgraced for plagiarizing portions of "How Opal Mehta Got Kissed, Got Wild, and Got a Life" and reports of a cheating outbreak on American college campuses, many claimed we had an epidemic of plagiarism on our hands.
Not so fast, says Richard Posner, a judge on the U.S. 7th Circuit Court of Appeals. In this clear and elegant argument, Posner lays out the differences between copyright infringement and plagiarism, and parses what he calls higher and lower forms of theoffense.
This may sound like a judge delivering a reduced sentence, but Posner wisely reminds we have only recently begun to prize "originality." As he shows, everyone from Shakespeare to Rembrandt to Coleridge did things that would be considered intellectual fraud today — but in their time were simply smart business practice (like Rembrandt signing portraits his assistants largely painted), finicky perfectionism (i.e., Coleridge endlessly revising his "Ancient Mariner") or flattery by way of imitation (such as Shakespeare lifting lines verbatim out of other works into his plays).
Clearly, though, we're in a different world. To judge plagiarists today, Pos-ner writes, we need to weigh what they have to gain from the infraction and what the damage will be to others. Students who plagiarize have much to gain and, if they're graded on a curve, make things harder for people who do their own work (Posner cites recent surveys indicating that up to one-third of American college students admit to cheating). But with newer plagiarism software on the market, chances that they'll get away with it decrease.
Posner isn't as worried about plagiarizing in popular fiction. As the events of last spring remind, it is easily detected and a potent reminder that when it comes to pulp entertainment, originality is hardly top priority. "What Viswanathan did," Posner concludes, "was no less — though maybe no more — reprehensible than what a manufacturer of toothpaste would be doing if he slapped the name of a better-known brand on his toothpaste."
John Freeman is president of the National Book Critics Circle.
Copyright © 2007 The Seattle Times Company
Book review: "Lance: The Making of the World's Greatest Champion:" a portrait of cycling's king
Book review: "Dangerous World of Butterflies": A threatened universe of dazzling creatures
Book review: "How to Sell": Novel spills a jeweler's deep, dark secrets
Book review: "Zhivago's Children": A brief flowering of thought after a dark time
'Running for My Life' is local top seller

2009 fireworks time lapse
With strict parking rules enforced at this year's July 4th celebration on Wallingford Ave North, less cars and more spectators filled the streets.
Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
nwjobs

Post a comment

Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
Tax tips for new independent professionals
Post a comment
nwautos

Choosing a new SUV? Weigh the impact your choice will have on your wallet and on the planet.
Post a comment
nwhomes

Find a new home or condo that fits your lifestyle.
Search New Developments
Builder Directory
- Landmark Smith Tower mostly vacant
- Property taxes: Appeals shoot up in King, Snohomish Counties
- Palin links resignation to 'higher calling' and blasts media in Facebook posting
- Shooting unveils very different sides of McNair
- Former NFL MVP McNair killed
- Hard times for tourist towns means good deals for travelers
- Tukwila residents rally against light-rail noise
- Quincy Jones remembers "the biggest entertainer on the planet": Michael Jackson
- Confessions of an Idol Addict | "American Idols" on tour: Live coverage from opening date
- Plasma and LCD beware; OLED screens ready to go mainstream
- Seattle Mariners at Boston Red Sox: 07/05 game thread
247 - Palin links resignation to 'higher calling' and blasts media in Facebook posting
177 - Hatred for the NBA runs deep, but don't take it out on the players
137 - Tukwila residents rally against light-rail noise
126 - Former NFL MVP McNair killed
113 - Property taxes: Appeals shoot up is King, Snohomish Counties
103 - Tent City on campus: UW stalls decision
101 - Anti-tax rally in Olympia attracts about 1,500
68 - Seeking your questions
53 - Mariners did their part, now they need help
46
- Property taxes: Appeals shoot up in King, Snohomish Counties
- Hard times for tourist towns means good deals for travelers
- Landmark Smith Tower mostly vacant
- Plasma and LCD beware; OLED screens ready to go mainstream
- Tent City on campus: UW stalls decision
- The People's Pharmacy | Estrogen mimicker found in sunscreen
- Toyota's Toyoda scolds execs for emulating U.S. car companies' mistakes
- Tukwila residents rally against light-rail noise
- Outdoor-theater season kicks off at Volunteer Park
- Seattle safety project: A snake shelter on Beacon Hill








